A declared output is written through a capture tool, but the dispatch-time
harness check read only the workflow's needs.captures. A workflow that
declared outputs without also writing needs: {captures: true} could name a
Kit profile whose adapter serves no capture tools; a required output then
parked with "output %q is required" instead of the profile being refused.
WorkflowInterface.Needs now reports captures for a non-empty Outputs beside
the declared needs, and the profile check and Kit launcher read it. The
needs: block keeps its meaning for a workflow that captures without
declaring outputs.
- internal/domain/workflow/task: Needs() derives captures; DeclaredNeeds
carries only the declared block.
- internal/daemon: pinTaskProfile and runKitTask read Needs().
- tests: parse-time derivation, and pinTaskProfile refusing an
outputs-declaring workflow against a Kit adapter with no capture MCP.
The poller, the forge webhook intake and the review scan built envelopes
without an Org, so every task and reaction keyed on the default org no
matter which org its identity served. Resolve the org through the State
Store's PrincipalSource (the existing org RPC over the staterpc client)
on the single publish paths:
- PublishTask stamps the envelope's identity org before encoding, so the
idempotency key is org/identity/owner/repo/number; a resolve failure
stops the publish instead of keying under a guess.
- PublishReaction is the one reaction write path, stamping the root org
when the webhook producer could not; the poll scan stamps its task's
already-resolved org, so both deliveries of one review key the same.
- The webhook receiver's inline publish closure moves onto the daemon
method, removing the second reaction write path.
The temp-repo fixtures in agentexec, domain/workflow and agentworker seeded
a repository and committed without disabling gpg signing, so a host with
commit.gpgsign=true and an agent-only SSH signing key failed those tests at
the fixture's own git call ("Couldn't get agent socket?").
Each producer now writes commit.gpgsign=false into the temporary repository's
own config, which also covers commits made inside the seeded repo by a
subprocess (the fake harness). A regression test per package pins the
fixture's hermeticity under a hostile global git config.
Decision 1 of docs/prds/pr-review-operator-response.md: the dashboard's
POST /api/tasks/{id}/action is the authoritative surface, chat's /approve
is a shortcut that posts every offered finding, and both reach the same
Service.Apply so one operator intent cannot be recorded as two decisions.
The action body now carries instructions (required by rereview) and the
finding keys an approve posts. taskactions.Service answers an offer
through the guarded RespondReviewGate write: approve records the
selection on the offer, rereview records the instructions, increments the
round and clears the offer, and a rereview with no instructions, with no
offer, or at the cap is refused as a conflict with nothing written. Chat
reaches the same service: chatTaskControllerAdapter.ApproveChatTask
delegates to b.taskActions() instead of its own requeue, which is what
removed the handler's hardcoded implement handoff -- feasibility's deliver
stage now names implement on the task before it waits, the invariant the
handler needs.
The payload crosses every hop it must: the NATS action request, the
gateway.v1 gRPC contract (regenerated), the LocalChatAdapter, and the
webui handler, which answers 400 for a rereview without instructions and
409 for the cap. A rereview event kind names its actor the way the
approval and rejection trios do.
taskactions.Task gains review_gate and rereview_rounds, and the two
surfaces' tests assert they agree.
The gate now writes its offer to the task's review_gate document before it
waits -- the scored findings, the head SHA, the pull request's identity
and the resuming workflow -- because the engine cannot resume a run
partway, so a resumed pipeline recomputes its findings and only the
recorded document is the review the operator saw
(docs/prds/pr-review-operator-response.md, "The review the operator
answers").
The document lives with the task column it encodes (internal/domain/
workflow/task), the way EncodeInputs does, and carries each finding as
opaque JSON beside the key an operator's selection names. That is what
lets the dashboard render and answer a gate without linking the workflow
engine -- cmd/archie-ui/architecture_test.go measures the linked binary,
and an operator-domain service importing the finding's own type linked
prreview into archie-ui. prreview owns the key derivation and the
finding's encoding, and the MaxRereviewRounds constant lives in the task
vocabulary beside the action names it answers with.
Intake restores the document into the run: a re-review's instructions
ride one labelled block in runLens's and runReviewer's missions only, and
an approve's recorded review is posted by phase 9 filtered by the
operator's selection, with the recomputed findings kept out of the output.
The gate does not wait again on an answered approve.
taskstate gains the rereview action the vocabulary needs -- offered for
waiting_human beside approve and reject, routed to queued -- whose
surfaces follow in the response channel.
The operator-approval gate needs its conversation with the operator
persisted before it waits and its answer threaded back
(docs/prds/pr-review-operator-response.md, Decision 2). review_gate is a
text column beside review_payload, encoded by the package that owns the
type; rereview_rounds is a bigint counted only by the new guarded write.
RespondReviewGate is the one write beside RetryTask/BeginRemediation: a
transition-table guard, one from-status check, an optional round
increment, and a requeue in one transaction. The re-review cap is
enforced in the row under the guard's lock, and a refusal leaves the
task waiting and the row untouched, surfaced as ErrRereviewCapReached
(added to the wire error table and the conformance battery). The column
joins the column-listing ListTaskSummaries projection and UpdateTask, so
the dashboard reads the offer and the store round-trips the count.
prReviewDecisionStages loses the withOperatorApproval flag: the shared
list the implement workflow splices (archie-core-afbk.7) never carries
the gate, and the standalone pipeline inserts it itself, immediately
before its merge gate (docs/prds/pr-review-operator-response.md, "The
gate is not reachable from archie's own PRs"). A structural test pins
both directions so a future edit cannot re-share the gate.
A workflow declares named, typed outputs beside its inputs
(task.WorkflowInterface.Outputs). A run writes each one once through a
capture tool named after the output, or from a deterministic Go stage via
TaskContext.WriteOutput; the finish write persists them on tasks.outputs
before the outcome transition. A wait:true caller receives its successful
callee's outputs through WorkflowCallStatus and publishes one as its own
through a call step's outputs assignment.
Build authority: docs/prds/workflow-call-outputs.md.
- save time: WorkflowInterface.Validate checks output names and types;
checkCallOutputs checks a call's assignment against both declarations
and refuses outputs over a wait:false call.
- run time: undeclared, mistyped and required-but-missing values park the
run; published callee values are re-checked against the caller's type.
- storage/wire: tasks.outputs (goose 0024), reset by each claim so the set
is attempt-scoped; an encoded set past the structured-payload bound is
refused, not clipped. Task.outputs_json and
WorkflowCallStatusResponse.outputs_json carry it; task.Caller keeps its
two methods.
- examples: firewall-contain calls firewall-investigate and publishes its
summary as its own output.
No process writes configuration through the dashboard: the write
handlers, their UpdateConfig/ResetConfig/UpdateRepoField seams and
ConfigView.Editable were deleted with the runtime config overlay
(31622ec5), and database-backed settings are written through the control
plane. That left producer-side residue behind:
- ConfigField.Editable and the descriptor literals setting it, which
emitted editable=true for fields no process can change, and which
ui/src/settings/types.ts's ConfigField deliberately omits from the
reader side of the wire shape
- ErrConfigUpdateUnavailable/ErrConfigUpdateInvalid, with neither a
producer nor a consumer since handleConfigUpdate was deleted
- comments pointing at handleConfigUpdate/UpdateConfig,
ConfigView.Editable, the overlay's overridden markers and a deleted
test name
The two Editable-only descriptor tests go with the field; the deleted
write path is what they pinned.
Closes the decision #1143 asked for. plugin_dir, module_dir, secret_engine_dir
and skills_dir keep their no-op validator, and the comment at that validator
now says so on purpose, with the two rules considered and refused:
- "must exist": all four consumers read a missing directory as an empty one by
design (plugin.LoadDir and secret.Registry.LoadDir return no entries and no
error on os.IsNotExist, loadModules skips an absent kind file, playbook.Load
returns an empty store, and internal/secret's TestLoadDirNonexistent pins the
no-error half), so the rule would turn deliberate emptiness into a failed
startup.
- "must be absolute" / "skills_dir under plugin_dir": no directory setting in
the repository is validated for shape, so a rule for these four alone is
arbitrary, and a boot-path validator over a stored document fails closed on
values the store already holds.
Deliberately no code change to either layer: configuration.validateDatabaseOwned
still has no say over the four, and the resource validator stays the single
no-op function with one obvious home for a rule.
Refs #1143
applyGeneralDefaults home-expanded secret_engine_dir, work_dir, state_dir and
chat.workspace but not plugin_dir, module_dir or skills_dir, while
config.example.toml tells operators to write all four as
~/.local/share/archie/<dir>. A literal "~" is not a directory: plugin.LoadDir
returns an empty set for it, loadModules finds no kind file, and skill
discovery falls back to the built-ins, all without an error naming the
mistake. Expand the three in the same place as the rest, so a value the
example advertises resolves to the directory the operator meant.
Test first: TestLoadExpandsConfiguredHomePaths gains the three fields (and
pins HOME to a temp dir instead of the runner's real one); it failed on the
three new assertions before this change.
No validator is added alongside: see the plugin-settings decision record for
why these four directories stay free-form.
Refs #1143
The sd_notify(3) client lived in internal/app/archied, so archie-messaging --
a process that must not import archied's composition -- could never announce
itself to systemd, and could therefore never be a Type=notify unit
(archie-core-g5g8).
The protocol client and the heartbeat sampler move to internal/sdnotify, a
cross-cutting leaf that imports nothing of ours. What stays in archied is
what is the daemon's own: which marker counts as progress (daemon.LastPollAt)
and how long the run loop may go between poll passes. The three entry points
that already announced keep announcing, unchanged.
The Messaging Service announces READY=1 at the point it declares itself
serving, the way the daemon, the Gateway and the State Store already do. No
unit is switched to Type=notify here: that is a separate decision, and
archie-messaging.service is still Type=simple.
An install that stayed in installed_packages left every contribution
unprojected: nothing made a package's workflow a usable org resource, and
nothing stopped it on removal. This lands projection for the workflow family,
the one kind whose org resource, validation and live read path all exist:
- storepkg.Service gains Projections (family -> projector): install resolves
each projected family's contributed names against the fetched
layer (FilesFromLayer), applies them, and on failure withdraws and removes
the half installation; remove withdraws before the record goes, so a failed
withdrawal keeps the package installed and usable.
- controlplane.WorkflowProjector merges the package's entries into the org's
workflow-definitions document — the same document the daemon's
WorkflowDefinitions client reads per dispatch, so a projected workflow is
usable at the next dispatch and a withdrawn one stops dispatching, without
restarts. A contributed id displacing an operator's own workflow is refused
(storepkg.ErrContributionCollision), never silently replaced.
- installed_package_contributions (migration 0023) records the entries a
package projected, so removal takes exactly its own contributions out.
- stateStoreDeps wires the projector set on the State Store's pool; the
composition is pinned by the live round-trip test over a real gRPC
connection.
Prompts, skills, MCP server definitions and default settings remain
unprojected: their contribution formats are not settled by docs/prds/store.md
and are left for their own slices rather than half-wired here.
{{.Scopes}} now substitutes the captured set as an ARRAY in the target
encoding, so a one-element set stays a one-element array rather than
collapsing to a bare string. An empty set REFUSES by name with an
actionable "re-run the setup terminal" message: the spec declares an
omission case for {{.PrimaryApiKey}} but none for {{.Scopes}}, and an empty
array would silently change the CLI's capability decisions.
{{.PrimaryApiKey}} now implements the spec's omit case: its enclosing key is
dropped from the structure, never emptied. archie resolves a service key
only to fill the egress grant and the container holds egress.Sentinel, so
there is never a key to render.
The renderer's input becomes OAuthFacts{Scopes, ExpiresAt} -- still the only
thing it receives about a stored token set, so a real access or refresh
token cannot reach the file and an unsourceable placeholder still refuses by
name (docs/prds/external-agent-harness.md, Verification).
A Kit's credentialFile cannot render {{.Scopes}} because nothing records the
granted scopes: the token response's `scope` field (RFC 6749 section 5.1,
space-delimited) was never read, and the token set had nowhere to hold it.
capture now parses `scope` into []string and keeps the previous set when the
field is absent or empty -- the same rule the refresh token follows, so a
refresh that does not repeat the scopes preserves what the login captured.
The set is carried end to end: Scopes on harnesssecret.Secret, in
harnessSecretPayload (JSON inside the existing encrypted envelope, so no
migration), on message HarnessSecret as `repeated string scopes = 8`, and
both ways through staterpc values.go. The proto field is load-bearing: the
daemon reads the token set over gRPC, so a local-struct-only field is
silently lost in production -- TestHarnessSecretConformance proves the round
trip in both its local and grpc modes.
An archie package declares its authority; nothing in the tree recorded the
operator's acceptance of it. This lands the acceptance-record slice of
docs/prds/store.md ("Authority"):
- storepkg.Authority gains Covers (the upper-bound predicate: equal or
narrower applies, wider does not) and Validate (forge-permission
vocabulary, no blank grants).
- Installed carries AcceptedAuthority (nil until accepted); install leaves it
unset, so an unaccepted package has no authority.
- AcceptPackageAuthority on the storepkg Manager records the acceptance
against the pinned digest and refuses grants the package does not declare
(storepkg.ErrAuthorityNotDeclared), carried over the wire.
- staterpc gains the admin-only AcceptPackageAuthority RPC;
InstalledPackage carries accepted_authority.
A Kit's credential@1 oauth.credentialFile was never rendered: Assemble set
SBX_CRED_<SVC>_MODE=oauth but no file was written, so the harness CLI started
logged out and never reached the token endpoint the egress proxy intercepts.
Render it at launch, for each bound OAuth-managed service that declares one:
the Kit's structure with its access/refresh sentinels, and the stored token
set's expiry for {{.ExpiresAt}}. The renderer's only input about a token set
is that expiry -- the tokens never cross into kit, so a real token cannot be
written (docs/prds/external-agent-harness.md, Verification).
Expiry renders as epoch milliseconds, the unit both in-spec OAuth credential
files use (Claude Code's expiresAt, OpenCode's expires). A placeholder archie
does not render, or a token placeholder with no declared sentinel, refuses the
launch rather than leaving a literal or an empty value in the file.
kitrun reads the store only for a service the run credential carries, and
fails closed when a rendered credential file has no captured token set.
The definitions query was built by hand, so it carried no org and the server
resolved the default one, while the enablement document read beside it and the
enablement write went to the default org outright. A caller in a non-default
org therefore read one org's definitions beside another org's enablement, and
toggled that other org's workflows.
workflowCollection now builds its query with controlplanerpc.QueryRequest, and
the three enablement reads and the write use org.OrgFromContext, so every one of
them names the org the principal put on the request context.
containedctx rejects a struct field of type context.Context, and both new
table tests stored one. Each case now carries what the caller put on the
context -- a builder in the org test, the org id in the client test -- and
builds the context inside the subtest.
The storage and wire contract already key resources by (org, kind), but no
caller sent an org, so every request acted in the default org. The org now
travels on the request context: webui's authorize middleware attaches the
verified principal's org, and one request-constructor per wire shape
(controlplanerpc's Query/History/Watch/CommandRequest) stamps it back, so a
call site cannot send the wrong org and a new one cannot forget it.
No behaviour change today: the shared token's principal is the default org's
owner, no production path creates another org, and a context with no principal
yields DefaultOrgID (what the server already derived from an empty org_id).
The dashboard could not name a workflow's declared inputs, so POST
/api/work-requests admitted a pr-review task with no pr_number, which then
failed at the workflow's intake stage (archie-core-06nq). The handler now takes
`inputs`, checks it against the workflow's declared interface before admitting
the task, and carries it through SpawnRequest.Inputs -> EnqueueChatTaskRequest;
the form renders one field per declared input, sends a declared number as a
number, and keeps Start disabled while a required input is empty.
Item 2 of the lane brief -- archie-core-afbk.12, review.precision_gate /
review.approve_before_post in the dashboard Config tab -- is deliberately NOT in
this commit. The surface it describes no longer exists in this tree; the
supervisor's decision was to stop it and re-scope it as its own lane, and the
facts it must start from belong in the branch's record:
* The Config-tab components were deleted by becb0b5e (2026-09-25, "the legacy
config catalog stops advertising fields the control plane owns"): ConfigSections.vue,
ConfigRow.vue, ConfigControl.vue, ConfigList.vue, ConfigNotices.vue,
ConfigUnavailable.vue, config-field.ts and sections.ts all went, because no
page used them. Descriptor entries in internal/webui/config_schema.go would
therefore change nothing a person can see: the only consumer of GET /api/config
is SystemModelsPage reading `catalog`; the per-field `schema` has no renderer.
* The config write seams went earlier, in 31622ec5 (2026-09-21, "delete the
runtime config overlay"): UpdateConfig, ResetConfig and UpdateRepoField are
gone and internal/webui/server.go serves only GET /api/config. Configuration
is written through the control plane.
* No control-plane resource carries review settings. executionSettingsDocument
(internal/app/controlplane/workflow_settings.go) and workflow.ExecutionSettings
carry only the four budget fields, and runtimeConfigFrom never layers
cfg.Review. That is exactly why the budget descriptors survive in the catalog
and review.* cannot: budgets are saved through workflow-execution-settings,
edited on the Task-execution page, so those entries match a real write path.
* The brief's precedent name is wrong: TestToolSettingsProjectionCarriesEveryMCPServerField
does not exist. The precedent is TestToolSettingsProjectionCarriesEveryMirroredField
(internal/app/controlplane/runtime_config_test.go:349).
Making review.* genuinely editable needs a carrying control-plane resource
(extend workflow-execution-settings or add a review-settings kind), a layering
step in internal/app/archied/control_plane.go, and the round-trip test that
precedent sets -- an unsettled design decision spanning packages this lane does
not own.
A message's attachments persist as metadata (messaging.Message.Media) and
cross the gateway wire, but the dashboard transcript rendered text only, so
a photo was invisible to the operator while the model had seen it.
The transcript view now carries the persisted metadata, and the browser
labels each attachment in the placeholder vocabulary the channels already
write into a message's text ('[photo]', '[document: report.pdf]'), with the
surviving metadata (mime, name, size, dimensions, duration) in the chip's
tooltip.
Bytes are never rendered: they are turn-scoped and stripped before a record
is stored, so there is nothing to fetch and no broken image or 404 link. The
platform file id is deliberately not served either -- it is a download
handle, not an address -- so the chip links out only when the attachment
itself carried a URL. A message with no attachments omits the media key, so
transcripts written before this change keep the payload they had.
prepareWorkspace always called worktree.Manager.Prepare, whose refresh
resets an existing clone onto origin/<base>. A remediation task -- one
continuing an archie-owned PR branch -- therefore lost that branch's
commits before its container started: StageResumeWorktree runs inside the
container against a tree already reset to base, and hybridTrees.Resume is
a no-op, so nothing restored origin/<branch>.
Route a task whose row names the remediate workflow through
Manager.Resume on the persisted Task.Branch, before Acquire. The branch is
read from the task row, never recomputed from the title or labels, and a
missing branch fails closed with a park rather than falling back to base.
Regression tests use a real bare remote: the prepared worktree's HEAD must
be the PR branch tip, a missing branch must park without touching the
worktree, and a non-remediation task must still start from base.
An empty org or kind, or either containing the '/' that joins them in the
audit record key, fails on read and write instead of colliding or reading as
an absent resource.
resources and resource_history are one document per org and kind, with
per-org advisory locks, request-ID idempotency and audit keys. The
control-plane Query/History/Command/Watch requests carry org_id; a request
naming none acts in the default org until the caller's org is derived
server-side.
The tar.gz extraction already refused ".." escapes, but it did so with
filepath.Rel and checked the resulting relative path. CodeQL's go/zipslip
query models a sanitizer only as strings.HasPrefix applied to the value that
reaches the file-system sink, so the derived relative-path check was invisible
to it and it flagged os.MkdirAll/os.WriteFile on the joined target
(alert 17: internal/infrastructure/prsource/archive.go).
Resolve destDir to an absolute path once, reject an absolute entry name
outright, then test the joined target against the destination root with
strings.HasPrefix -- the PrefixCheck guard the query recognises. Behaviour is
unchanged: a ".." entry is still refused, and a wrapper directory is still
stripped. Adds an absolute-entry rejection test and a test proving an escaping
entry writes nothing outside destDir.
Telegram dropped every incoming photo, document, video and audio
message: the default handler required message text, and nothing on the
turn path knew media existed. The receiving path now closes the gap
end to end.
- telegram: extract the attachment from the update (largest photo, plus
document, video, video-note, audio and voice kinds), download its
bytes on the turn lane through getFile + the Bot API file link with a
20 MB gate, submit the turn with the attachment, and answer
unsupported content kinds (sticker, location, contact, poll) with a
clear notice instead of silence
- messaging: Inbound carries turn-scoped transport media and
MediaAttachment a Data field for in-process bytes; Message gains
Media attachment metadata which stores persist (Postgres jsonb via
migration 0020, memory store) with Data stripped at the persist
boundary, and pb.Message carries the metadata on the gateway wire
- gateway: TurnModelRequest threads the turn's media to the model seam
- archied: the chat turn model merges the attachments into the final
user message as ai-sdk image/file part entries, so vision-capable
models see the file for the turn it arrived in; stored history keeps
the placeholder note plus caption
Session log: messages carry what was sent as data (the attachment
metadata), not just prose. Transcript rendering of attachments and a
re-look capability are tracked as archie-core-jaba.
A workflow-enablement control-plane resource lists, per org, the workflows
that org has disabled. A binding targeting a disabled workflow is skipped at
dispatch like an unarmed one, is refused on save, and is flagged on the
binding list; the workflows page toggles it. Bindings now carry the org_id
column they already had in storage, over the State Store wire too.
Org-owned workflow definitions are deferred to a follow-up bead: they need
the caller's org, which the access chain resolves.
DecodeResult accepted any value reflect could convert, so a number for a
string field silently became the rune string (42 became "*"), and a declared
field absent from the map read as its zero value. Both are now reported: a
value is accepted only at the field's declared type, and every declared field
must be present.
That is the boundary the typed CEL environment promises, and it is live now
that the action runner decodes every result into actions.<id>.result before a
later expression reads it. D5 in docs/prds/multi-action-playbooks.md records
the rule.
An args value that cannot be evaluated aborts its playbook run: the action and
every later action in that playbook do not run, other playbooks matching the
event still run, and the task is unaffected. J3's skip-and-continue rule stays
specific to `when`, because a predicate has a meaningful false and data does
not.
Ratified now that the action runner is the production consumer, and locked by a
call-site test that fails if the rule is weakened to a skip. Drop the stale
"unbuilt decisions" header line, since J1, J2 and the Result schema
declarations have shipped.