A retry now carries the operator's worktree choice (refresh onto the base
branch or continue the work already pushed on the task branch) from the
dashboard through the task action to the daemon dispatch, and persists it
on the task row so it survives a reload. The daemon resolves the mode from
the task, never from the workflow; BeginRemediation records continue
explicitly so a remediation still resumes its pull request branch.
prepareWorkspace chose between Manager.Prepare (refresh onto base) and a
separate Manager.Resume, and Manager.Resume only opened an
already-prepared clone. A remediation whose local worktree the terminal
cleanup removed, an expired volume dropped, or a different host never had
could therefore never be resumed, and the retry path had no way to select
the mode that continues pushed work.
Unify the two matched methods into Prepare(..., Target): Fresh resets onto
origin/<base>, a non-empty Target resets onto origin/<that branch>, and
either target clones a missing worktree. The daemon's retry path selects
the target from the task row and passes the persisted branch, so a resume
lands on the branch the open PR lives on and fails closed when it is not
on the remote.
Delete the container-mode no-op resume (hybridTrees.Resume and the
resumableTrees capability) now that the daemon owns it. The remediate
workflow no longer stages a resume, and the retired remediate.resume step
word stays resolvable as an inert stage: a stored definition is validated
as a whole collection, so a removed word would fail every workflow to
decode, not just its own.
A declared output is written through a capture tool, but the dispatch-time
harness check read only the workflow's needs.captures. A workflow that
declared outputs without also writing needs: {captures: true} could name a
Kit profile whose adapter serves no capture tools; a required output then
parked with "output %q is required" instead of the profile being refused.
WorkflowInterface.Needs now reports captures for a non-empty Outputs beside
the declared needs, and the profile check and Kit launcher read it. The
needs: block keeps its meaning for a workflow that captures without
declaring outputs.
- internal/domain/workflow/task: Needs() derives captures; DeclaredNeeds
carries only the declared block.
- internal/daemon: pinTaskProfile and runKitTask read Needs().
- tests: parse-time derivation, and pinTaskProfile refusing an
outputs-declaring workflow against a Kit adapter with no capture MCP.
The poller, the forge webhook intake and the review scan built envelopes
without an Org, so every task and reaction keyed on the default org no
matter which org its identity served. Resolve the org through the State
Store's PrincipalSource (the existing org RPC over the staterpc client)
on the single publish paths:
- PublishTask stamps the envelope's identity org before encoding, so the
idempotency key is org/identity/owner/repo/number; a resolve failure
stops the publish instead of keying under a guess.
- PublishReaction is the one reaction write path, stamping the root org
when the webhook producer could not; the poll scan stamps its task's
already-resolved org, so both deliveries of one review key the same.
- The webhook receiver's inline publish closure moves onto the daemon
method, removing the second reaction write path.
prepareWorkspace always called worktree.Manager.Prepare, whose refresh
resets an existing clone onto origin/<base>. A remediation task -- one
continuing an archie-owned PR branch -- therefore lost that branch's
commits before its container started: StageResumeWorktree runs inside the
container against a tree already reset to base, and hybridTrees.Resume is
a no-op, so nothing restored origin/<branch>.
Route a task whose row names the remediate workflow through
Manager.Resume on the persisted Task.Branch, before Acquire. The branch is
read from the task row, never recomputed from the title or labels, and a
missing branch fails closed with a park rather than falling back to base.
Regression tests use a real bare remote: the prepared worktree's HEAD must
be the PR branch tip, a missing branch must park without touching the
worktree, and a non-remediation task must still start from base.
A workflow-enablement control-plane resource lists, per org, the workflows
that org has disabled. A binding targeting a disabled workflow is skipped at
dispatch like an unarmed one, is refused on save, and is flagged on the
binding list; the workflows page toggles it. Bindings now carry the org_id
column they already had in storage, over the State Store wire too.
Org-owned workflow definitions are deferred to a follow-up bead: they need
the caller's org, which the access chain resolves.
Approving a waiting_human task requeues it under implement, but the requeue
only writes status, workflow and park_reason: the previous run's definition
stays pinned. pinWorkflowDefinition then returned early on any non-empty
stored definition, having checked only that the YAML matched its own recorded
digest -- a property of the write, never of the task -- so the dispatch went
out carrying a definition naming feasibility over a row naming implement.
That is the pair the worker's compile refuses
(agentworker.CompilePinnedWorkflow: "pinned workflow definition does not match
task identity"), so the task parked again immediately, identically on every
further approval, leaving decline the only working operator action.
A pin's identity is part of what makes it valid, not an assumption. The
producer now reads the id the stored definition declares (workflow.DefinitionID
answers that from YAML alone, without the step vocabulary) and re-pins from the
active collection whenever it disagrees with the task's workflow column. A pin
that is present, digest-valid and id-consistent is still a strict no-op, so an
operator's active definition override survives a dispatch unchanged, and a pin
whose YAML does not match its recorded digest is still refused rather than
silently overwritten.
Closes#1235
review_pr self-omitted since 7299b923 deleted the synchronous reviewer it
called. It is rebuilt on the task enqueue path everything else uses: the
tool resolves the identity's configured repo, then queues a pr-review task
naming the pull request through the workflow's declared pr_number input,
which is the same generic input mechanism a watched-repos binding uses.
That input has to reach the store with the task, so
EnqueueChatTaskRequest gains inputs_json and the tasks insert writes the
inputs column directly. StampTaskBinding no longer writes it: the insert is
now the column's only writer, and a chat task must not acquire binding
provenance just to carry an input.
ChatPRReviewer, its result shape and the reviewer wiring are deleted with
the path they served.
Watched-repos needs no bespoke webhook-parsing code: the existing
generic capture+binding system (internal/infrastructure/captureintake,
internal/domain/binding.Binding) already turns any inbound webhook into
a task on any workflow, via a dashboard-editable matcher, CEL filter
and payload-to-input mapping. pr-review just needed to become a
binding-targetable workflow.
- Workflow gains an Interface field (task.WorkflowInterface) so a
Go-literal builtin can declare inputs the same way a YAML-defined one
does; ShippedDefinitions emits an inputs: block only when non-empty,
so every other builtin's generated YAML is byte-identical to before.
- PRReview() declares pr_number as a required number input.
- Task gains EffectivePRNumber(): PRNumber when a producer set it
directly (archie's own PRs), else the pr_number input a binding
assigned generically through Task.Inputs. Handles json.Number (the
store's round-trip encoding), float64 and int.
- The daemon resolves it once in acquireTaskContainer, before the task
brief is written and before the pr-review prefetch runs, so
everything downstream agrees. stagePRIntake falls back to the same
resolution for any dispatch path that bypasses container acquisition,
and fails loudly if neither PRNumber nor the input is set.
An operator wires up watched-repos entirely through the dashboard: a
Binding matching the webhook's source, a CEL filter for pull_request
events, workflow: pr-review, and an Inputs mapping pr_number from the
payload. No code change needed for a new repo or a new source.
Operator/chat trigger remains open, left as a precise continuation:
EnqueueChatTask is part of the State Store's protobuf-generated gRPC
contract (proto/state/v1/state.proto), not just a Go interface --
extending it for a generic inputs parameter needs a proto field
addition + regen, a new SQL query (StampTaskBinding cannot be reused,
since it unconditionally stamps binding_id/version, which a plain chat
task must never carry), and updates across staterpc's client/server and
~20 call sites. Real plumbing, not a quick tool rewrite -- scoped
correctly as its own pass rather than rushed here.
Adds the mechanism pr-review's watched-repos and operator triggers need:
before acquiring a pr-review task's container, the daemon fetches the pull
request's metadata, diff and head snapshot over its own credentialed forge
client (prefetchPRReview, using the already-built HTTP-based prsource.Source
from 600a0553) and writes the result under workDir/.archie-pr-review -- the
same host directory Docker bind-mounts into the container. The container-side
pipeline reads it back with prsource.MountSource, a local filesystem read, no
network call and no credential.
This follows the existing convention exactly (docs/development/agent.md,
"Giving the agent something new": "the daemon's own administrative token
never enters a container") and the same pattern WriteTaskJSON already uses
for the task brief -- prepare on the host before the container starts,
because the container binds the directory. No RPC service, no environment
variable, no exception to the stated rule.
Add review.precision_gate and review.approve_before_post to config,
threaded through TaskConfig/ForTask/ToConfig so the pr-review workflow
reads them under archie-agent too, not just in-process.
stagePRPrecisionGate runs between review and verification, filtering
findings down to concrete, evidenced defects when the dial is on;
stagePROperatorApproval ends the run in waiting_human right after
synthesis, before the merge gate, when approval is required and
findings exist. Both are off by default and fail open on a broken
agent call, matching the pipeline's existing recall-first fallbacks.
Filed follow-ups: afbk.11 for the actual operator-response resume
mechanics (post/reject/re-review with instructions, the 2-round cap --
genuinely needs either a small Task schema addition or a documented
Notes-encoding decision, a call for whoever wires afbk.7's triggers)
and afbk.12 for exposing the two flags in the dashboard Config tab.
kitrun ran the first Kit of a profile's list as the container image, so
every mixin's layers (its tools, skills and staged context) were dropped
without a refusal. A profile's `kit` is now one digest-pinned reference:
a workload Kit, or a published Kit set, which the Kit spec's frontend
merges from a workload and its mixins into one image. archie composes no
Kits itself, and a bare mixin is refused with a pointer to publishing a
set. kit.Compose had no production caller left and is removed.
BREAKING CHANGE: `[containers.profiles.X] kit` and the agent-profiles
document's `kit` are a string, not a list. A stored list fails to decode
and must be rewritten as the one workload or set reference.
Part of archie-core-egkf.6.
A worktree terminal cleanup keeps (uncaptured or unreadable work) now has a
reap path: archiving calls Daemon.RemoveWorktree for the owning identity's
trees, and the keep logs name archive as the way out. The no-change cleanup
test reports completed through one direct transition instead of reaching
merged via a faked pr_open hop.
qdbo.8 follow-ups: ActionTarget names each action's destination status, the
taskactions service records through it, and a test proves every offered action
is a legal transition. worktreeHoldsUncapturedWork now keeps a worktree on any
stat error other than not-exist. The dashboard action test covers completed, and
agent-system.md drops the no-state-machine hazard qdbo.5 resolved.
Plan item 5 of docs/prds/execution-tree-state-machine.md (archie-core-1217).
Until now a stop was a context cancel plus a caller-side transition, and the
step rows a worker still held running could never be told: the execution moved
while the work carried on, and the old interrupt-first ordering existed only
because the record could not defend itself. The step table can: the PRD's
ordering -- the store is the record, the context cancel is the delivery --
became safe the moment a worker's next step write fails ErrStaleTransition
against a cancelled step.
- storecontract.ExecutionCanceller and the CancelExecution RPC: one
transaction moves every non-terminal StepExecution of the execution's
current attempt to cancelled (one event row each, in the same
transaction), and the execution itself to the status the operator action
names, under the shared transition table with its audit row. Staleness is
decided before legality, the way guardTransition decides it. Earlier
attempts are never rewritten. Deliberately administrative: the
deny-by-default grant rule covers it, pinned by a test.
- taskactions.Service routes stop, cancel, abandon and reject through it and
the old Transition/CancelTask combinations are deleted; the daemon's
in-memory cancel is demoted to the delivery hook the PRD names, called
after the store record.
- The gateway's chat controller records first and delivers second, the same
order, and records even when no runtime is wired here (a standalone
gateway cannot reach the daemon's goroutines): the record is what unsticks
a lost-cancel task, and the delivery is best effort. StopRunning and
TaskRuntime.CancelRunningTasks are deleted outright -- no production
caller remained once the task_action tool owned stopping, and the daemon's
CancelRunningTasks/runningTasks.stopAll go with them.
- The gateway's chat adapter writes through CancelExecution instead of a
bare Transition, so chat /cancel and the dashboard's action service land
on the same path.
PRD decisions recorded here:
- Each cancelled step's event row is stage_finish with {cancelled: true} and
the reason as its detail -- the exact-one-event-per-step-transition rule
covers the pending -> cancelled transition too, even for a step that never
ran.
- A parked cancel carries the needs_human class, matching the Transition
path this replaces; the transient class stays with parkRunningTask's
unwind parks, which now meet ErrStaleTransition for cancelled runs and are
ignored there.
- Cancelling a wait:true callee is deferred to #1216's agent-call children:
the callee's own tree and the wait flag are what make
"cancelling a caller cancels each callee it waits on" decidable, and the
callee writes it cannot fake are this issue's half of the contract.
- RecoverStale's interrupted sweep is plan item 6, untouched here.
docs/prds/external-agent-harness.md (Credentials) and orgs-and-access.md:
egress.Resolver had no production implementation, and no run carried a
credential naming the org secrets its identity is granted, so a Kit's
required credential@1 was refused at the proxy and no harness run
authenticated (archie-core-egkf.11).
Two things, as scoped (this does not attempt #1026's full run-credential
consolidation replacing WorktreeGrantIssuer/StateStoreGrantIssuer -- that
PRD item is real, separate, and still open; this is deliberately narrower):
1. A run credential naming granted secrets: config.CredentialBinding maps a
Kit credential@1 service to a secret; config.Config/IdentityConfig gain
Org and GrantedCredentials (a per-identity allowlist of service names,
reusing the existing per-identity config-override pattern DiffCapLines
already uses, not a new Cedar/Authorizer integration -- KindSecret policy
objects exist in internal/domain/access but assembling a full Principal
is #1026's job, not a two-line addition here). config.ContainerConfig.
BoundCredentials computes the declared (Kit) ∩ granted (identity) ∩
org-matched intersection Sam's own rule requires: neither side widens
the other, proven by a mutation-checked test flipping each of the three
independently.
2. egress.GrantResolver: the production Resolver, holding only what a
caller explicitly Grant-ed one run, replaced wholesale (not merged) on
a repeated Grant, gone entirely on RevokeGrant. kitrun.Launcher.Launch
computes the intersection per launch and resolves real values through
the existing secret registry (SecretResolver), Grants it before the
proxy session opens, and Release/error-path rollback (a new shared
Launcher.release) always revokes it.
Course-corrected mid-implementation (flagged by Sam): credential bindings
first landed as a boot-time config.ContainerConfig.Credentials field
captured once into Launcher.Bindings -- exactly the "parses but is not a
resource" trap CLAUDE.md warns about, and inconsistent with agent-profiles
(#1207) making a Kit profile apply without a restart. Rebuilt as its own
live control-plane resource, CredentialBindingsKind ("credential-bindings"),
following the agent-profiles/container-runtime-policies split precisely:
config.ContainerConfig.Credentials is json:"-", [containers].credentials
is only its seed, and kitrun.Launcher now holds *config.Holder (not a
captured slice) and reads Containers.Credentials fresh on every Launch.
Org/GrantedCredentials were already read fresh per dispatch (d.configFor
inside runKitTask, never cached), so no equivalent fix was needed there.
Deliberately not built: identities and grants as their own State Store
resource (orgs-and-access.md's "Org owns ... identities and their grants").
Identities are entirely config.toml-defined today with no control-plane
resource at all; moving GrantedCredentials alone into one would put half
an identity in two places. That migration is identities' own scope, not
credential bindings'.
docs/prds/external-agent-harness.md ("Contract"): workflow definition
validation must reject a stage whose needs the selected harness cannot
meet -- capture tools without an adapter, or a gate retry without a
resume verb. The step vocabulary had no static way to declare either.
Added task.WorkflowInterface.Needs{Captures, GateRetries}, parsed and
validated (GateRetries >= 0) the same way Inputs/Repository already are.
Only a Kit profile is checked against it: an image profile's built-in
agent loop always supports both, so Needs constrains only the harness path.
Two enforcement points, chosen for where each fact is actually known
without a network fetch at save time:
- Captures vs adapter is knowable from config alone (profile.Adapter, the
agentexec.harnessAdapters table), so daemon.pinTaskProfile checks it
right where it already resolves the profile (validateProfileMeetsNeeds),
parking the task the same way an unconfigured profile already does.
- GateRetries vs the Kit's actual agent-sessions resume verb is only known
once the Kit composition is fetched, which kitrun.Launcher.Launch
already does -- so kit.ValidateNeeds runs there (new kitrun.Request.
GateRetries field, threaded from the workflow's parsed Needs in
daemon.runKitTask) rather than inventing an image-fetching workflow-save
validator.
Deliberately NOT built: "a Kit profile named by no workflow is a
validation error" (external-agent-harness.md "Selection"). Read literally
("a Kit profile [that is] named by no workflow"), this is a
cross-resource check -- an agent-profiles entry unreferenced by anything
in workflow-definitions -- and no control-plane Definition validator can
see another resource today (Definition.Validate is a pure []byte->error
function by design, matching every existing resource kind). Building
that crossing is a real, separate piece of infrastructure with its own
ordering questions (does defining a Kit profile before its workflow now
fail?), not a two-line addition, so it is left for a follow-on rather
than bolted on here.
Also fixes a test bug caught by rerunning with a short -timeout per
instruction: TestRunKitTaskThreadsGateRetriesToTheLauncher's fake NATS
subscriber never responded, so runKitTask's call into runViaAgent blocked
forever waiting for a reply bounded by a zero (unconfigured) wall-clock
budget. Fixed by responding, matching the sibling test's pattern.
docs/prds/external-agent-harness.md's "Selection" says a stage may name a
different profile than its workflow's. Investigated before writing new
runtime code, per instruction not to build container-switching machinery:
a Kit task runs in one container provisioned for one profile (Container
layout), so a stage needing a different profile cannot be a mid-container
runner swap without inventing per-stage re-provisioning the PRD does not
ask for and Container layout argues against ("cost scales with the run,
not with how many agents it fans out to").
The requirement is already met by workflow.call plus per-task profile
resolution, both pre-existing: postgres.Store.StartCall stores the
callee's OWN Workflow name (not the caller's), and daemon.pinTaskProfile
resolves a task's profile purely from its own WorkflowDefinitionYAML.
Chaining these means a stage wanting a different profile is its own
callee workflow, started via workflow.call, exactly the way
event-automation.md already describes ("the callee runs as its own run
with its own agent profile").
No new production code, only a PRD clarification (dev-docs regenerated)
plus TestWorkflowCallGivesACalleeItsOwnProfile (daemon_test.go), which
closes the gap between two already-tested facts that nothing previously
stated together: TestWorkflowCallerConformance (staterpc) proves a
callee's Workflow field is independent of its caller's; this proves that
independence is what makes Kit-vs-image runner selection independent too,
composing a caller pinned to an image profile with a real StartCall-
created callee pinned to a Kit profile.
The execution transition table refuses most of the pairs shipped fixtures
wrote to build a finished task -- running -> merged, queued -> parked,
queued -> waiting_human, queued -> merged -- so those fixtures fail the
moment the store enforces it.
internal/taskstate/taskstatetest seeds a status by walking the table's
legal edges (shortest route, computed from taskstate.CanTransition), so a
fixture cannot write an illegal pair and fails loudly when no route
exists. The fixtures in internal/daemon, internal/app/archied,
internal/webui and internal/infrastructure/postgres go through it, and
the table's own test names running -> merged as refused.
The cleanup added for no-change runs removed a `completed` task's
worktree whenever it had no PR. agent.run also ends its workflow
`StatusCompleted`, and it works in a real clone whose uncommitted edits
are the deliverable, so the status alone was enough to delete the work:
no commit, no push, no other copy of those edits anywhere.
Cleanup now reads the worktree first and skips a dirty one. A worktree
whose status cannot be read is kept too -- a wrong keep costs disk, a
wrong delete costs the work -- while one that is not on disk has nothing
to keep. The lifecycle fixtures prepare a real clone now, which is the
only shape the daemon ever cleans up, and the cancelled-context test
still cancels only the cleanup call.
Every install serves from Postgres, so the legacyread/legacyimport packages,
the archie-state-store import command, the boot gate that refused to serve
over unimported SQLite files, and db_path (which only located those files)
go. Migration 0010 drops the import_completion table.
Each credential is now only a {engine, key} secret reference. A stale
token_env in a file is reported at startup as an unrecognised key.
nats.token_env stays (no secret-ref form), and providers.api_key_env stays:
it is the carrier the resolver writes each resolved key's env name into.
Workflow definitions declare inputs, repository (none, optional or
required; default required) and profile. A binding assigns each input
from a mapped parameter or a constant and may take its repository from a
parameter, which must name a configured repo; both are checked when the
binding is saved and again at dispatch. Inputs travel as structured task
data (tasks.inputs, the task brief, and a JSON block in the agent's
mission), never as body text.
A task with no repository runs in a per-task scratch workspace with no
clone and no publication grant. The agent.run step runs one mission
without a repository and finishes the task in the new completed status.
Agent profiles live under [containers.profiles.<name>]: an image and an
allowlist over the tools archie adds (MCP, scripts, plugins).
[containers].image is the default profile; an unconfigured profile parks
the task. The workflow is now pinned before the container starts so the
profile can choose its image.
Also stop two archied tests writing embedded NATS state into the package
directory, refuse an empty state_dir for embedded NATS, and drop the NATS
store files an earlier lane commit tracked.
The State Store, event capture and Gateway conversations already serve from
PostgreSQL. This deletes internal/store and internal/infrastructure/edastore,
the SQLite gateway session store and openProductionTaskStore, and the -db
recovery path on a legacy task file; backup, restore, validate and rollback
work on the database database_url names.
- The binding-secret cipher moves to internal/infrastructure/bindingcipher and
ToolCall to internal/infrastructure/postgres.
- NewSessionStoreMemory is now a pure in-memory store that passes the shared
SessionStore conformance suite.
- Tests run against PostgreSQL through internal/infrastructure/postgres/pgstore;
legacyimport/legacyfixture writes the legacy files the import and the boot
gate read.
- The cron dialect is owned in internal/domain/scheduling, so
github.com/pocketbase/pocketbase and pocketbase/dbx leave go.mod.
modernc.org/sqlite stays for the one-time import (legacyread).
- The UI and Messaging architecture gates ban the Postgres and legacy readers
in place of internal/store.
A mapping belongs to an event type and is checked against its inferred
schema on save. Each event a mapping resolves is counted once in
mapping_matches (migration 0008), read back as match_count and
last_matched_at. Bindings carry an optional CEL filter over the mapping's
parameters, checked on save. The per-source unique indexes are dropped:
every armed binding whose mapping matches the capture's event type and
whose filter admits it dispatches once, claimed in the per-binding ledger
before its task is enqueued. The State Store gains RecordMappingMatch and
the new mapping and binding fields.
A source is the capture endpoint: a UUIDv7 path by default or a unique
URL-safe custom path, signed by default with an Archie-generated secret
(encrypted via the bindings cipher), or unsigned after an approval.
Intake verifies X-Hub-Signature-256/X-Signature-256 against the source
secret before redaction; an unauthenticated event on a signed source is
captured but never dispatched, an event on an approved unsigned source
dispatches and is marked unsigned. The binding secret is retired; migration
0006 derives sources from existing binding and capture source strings,
moving each binding's secret onto its source. SourceStore crosses the
State Store gRPC contract. The dashboard gains a sources panel and flags
unsigned in the capture inspector, binding list and task timeline.
Nothing moved a binding out of draft except an unrelated edit, so a newly created binding could not be approved and the dashboard showed no Approve button. Draft is removed; existing draft rows are promoted to pending_approval when the EDA store opens.
Domain fields ParkClass/RemediationRounds landed in 0d82f3fa; this is
the wire and daemon half. Task gains park_class (32) and
remediation_rounds (33) and maps both directions; the classified park
write crosses the wire as ParkTask on a narrow TaskParker contract
(TaskLifecycle stays under the 8-method cap), with conformance
coverage local + grpc including the stale-guard sentinel and
needs_human normalization. Every daemon park site now states its
class: terminal for a repo that left config and a retired identity,
transient for the environmental parks (worktree, storage, grants,
taskrun), and identityMayAct returns the class beside its reason.
Sequencing steps 6 and 7 of pr-review-remediation.md: the consumer
landed in e8d79b38, and these are the two sources that feed it.
Webhook (decision 2, low latency): the GitHub receiver decodes
pull_request_review and pull_request_review_comment events behind the
existing HMAC verification and publishes the same typed reaction the
poller produces, keyed source-independently so PublishUnique collapses
the two sources. Only submitted/created carry a verdict to remediate;
edited and dismissed are acknowledged. Reaction deliveries are
rate-limited per source (decision 6's 'add when the receiver gains a
second event family'), and the reaction path carries no dispatch
predicate -- eligibility is the consumer's owned-PR lookup.
Poll (both forges, the no-webhook backstop): one shared scan over all
pr_open tasks, each with the forge client its own identity owns
(reconcilePRs's shape), listing reviews and comments since per-task
persisted high-water marks and skipping the owning identity's bot user
(decision 5's own-comment exclusion, which the poll is positioned to
make identity-correct).
The cursors are two, not one: review IDs and comment IDs are independent
forge sequences, and a combined high-water mark would silently skip
reviews once a larger comment ID landed. watch_comment_id -- dead since
the comment-watch design it was created for never shipped -- carries the
comment cursor; review_cursor is a new presence-gated migrator column,
and SetReviewCursors is its guarded RPC (pr_open only, so cursors never
move under a run that owns the task). forge.ReviewComment gains ReviewID
so a comment is collectable into its review's unit (decision 5) on both
forges, and forge.Review gains Body so poll-delivered reviews carry
their summary.
Note: the store/proto/facade half of this work landed early in d296484a
under a release session's message -- a shared-checkout collision, kept
rather than rewritten; that commit carries the review_cursor migration
and the SetReviewCursors contract, this one carries the producers.
The remediate workflow was registered but had no trigger: the reaction
stream was provisioned, the envelope, resolver and owned-PR lookup all
landed, yet nothing consumed the stream (pr-review-remediation.md's
sequencing left the consumer for this step). The daemon now drains the
reaction stream each cycle, before the task drain, so a reaction can be
claimed in the same pass that carried it.
Per decision 3, the store's owned-PR lookup is the authorization
boundary: an unmatched, merged or closed PR drops with a counter, and a
public reaction can never start an agent against a foreign repository.
Per decision 5, a review is the unit of remediation -- its comment
events are appended to the unit while it is queued and dropped once the
run is claimed (the round cap bounds the exchange); a standalone comment
is its own unit of one; approved reviews never remediate; and archie's
own comments, matched on the owning identity's bot user, are excluded so
its replies cannot retrigger it.
The guarded BeginRemediation/UpdateReviewPayload store methods are the
dedup: the pr_open -> queued transition carries the review unit in the
same write, so re-delivered reactions fail the status guard instead of
starting a second round. Both are new StateStoreService RPCs following
the Requeue shape, covered by the local/grpc conformance battery.
EventsSince no longer depends on events.id being monotonic. The feed now
pages a total order over (at, id): at is a fixed-width, lexicographically
sortable UTC timestamp (storecontract.EventCursorLayout) and id is only a
deterministic tie-break for rows sharing one timestamp. The cursor is an
opaque string on the wire (EventsSinceRequest.cursor), carried verbatim as
the SSE id: field and echoed back via Last-Event-ID, so EventSource resume
needs no client change.
A new idempotent migration normalises pre-existing RFC3339Nano at values to
the fixed-width layout before finishTaskMigration, and idx_events_at backs
the new query. Legacy integer and garbage cursors degrade to "from the
beginning", preserving the old failed-ParseInt-yields-0 behaviour.
Amends the "Dashboard live event delivery" decision's cursor-cannot-skip
justification, which previously rested on commit-order id assignment.
The event-capture tables (captures, mappings, bindings, binding_dispatches,
playbook_dispatches) now live in PocketBase-owned collections and their ids
are opaque record ids rather than autoincrement integers. The task lifecycle
stays on SQLite: tasks/transitions/events carry FIFO claim ordering, id-cursor
pagination and the task-grant map, none of which gain anything from being
hand-editable. binding_dispatches.task_id is the single seam and stays an
integer addressing that store.
BREAKING: CapturedEvent.Id, Mapping.Id, Binding.Id and Binding.MappingId are
strings on the wire, as are the ids in the capture/mapping/binding requests.
RecordDispatchRequest.task_id is deliberately unchanged.
What the collections buy, beyond storage: a payload nobody has modelled yet is
inspectable, a mapping is editable at runtime, and a binding's relation to its
mapping is enforced. The old schema declared no FOREIGN KEY on that link, so a
dangling mapping_id was previously possible and is now refused.
Behaviour preserved deliberately, each recovered from the SQLite version
rather than reimplemented from memory:
- draft -> pending_approval -> armed, with approval only from
pending_approval and an edit always returning a binding for re-approval
- one binding per source, guarded on insert, update and approve
- an empty secret on update keeps the stored one, so an edit form that does
not echo it back cannot silently disarm a binding
- ErrMappingNotFound / ErrBindingNotFound on a missing delete target
- sentinels are re-exported from storecontract, never redefined: staterpc
matches on exact canonical message to rehydrate them, so a second
definition would break errors.Is across the wire invisibly
Two implementation notes worth keeping:
- at-most-once dispatch is now a unique index rather than INSERT OR IGNORE.
Only the unique-violation maps to ErrAlreadyDispatched; any other save
error is returned, because treating them all as "already recorded" would
turn the ledger into a silent at-least-once dispatcher.
- captures store received_at themselves at nanosecond precision in a
fixed-width layout. PocketBase autodates are millisecond and record ids
are random, so same-millisecond captures would otherwise order
arbitrarily; the old store got insertion order free from autoincrement.
- ListUndispatchedCaptures is raw SQL: the anti-join is a subquery and
PocketBase's filter DSL is not SQL. A read fires no hooks either way.
Adds tool_calls, which had no persistence at all: tool calls only ever reached
the on-disk task log, readable as text but never queryable or watchable.
Nothing writes it yet.
The binding secret cipher moves with the bindings it protects.
Pass 2 of archie-core-nx30. Pass 1 typed each prior action's result in
the CEL env; this pass wires that typing through the loader, module
schemas, and daemon, and removes the now-redundant id classifier.
Loader shape (D2): one playbook is exactly one workflow action
(unchanged) OR one or more module actions; the shapes never mix. Mixed,
unsupported, or zero actions fail the load naming the playbook.
playbook.Load now takes a KindSchemas source (a small interface this
package defines, satisfied by *module.ModuleRegistry) so playbook grows
no module import. Callers: bootstrap.loadEDAPlaybooks passes b.modules;
daemon and playbook tests pass module.New().
Per-playbook env (D3): each action's when and args values compile against
an env built from the PRIOR actions' ids typed by their kinds' Result
structs (expr.NewEnv(DeclaredResult{ID,Type})). event stays dyn. An
undeclared id, a forward reference, or a field the kind's Result lacks is
a compile-time undefined-field error.
Args schema (D4): an args key the kind's Args struct does not define
fails the load. An args VALUE whose compiled type mismatches the field
type is left as a named gap (not cheap without leaking cel-go type kinds
into playbook and handling dyn reads); a wrong-typed value still surfaces
at module invoke, not load.
D1: Store.Dispatch routes workflow playbooks only, so an action playbook
cannot hijack the definition pin. bootstrap.loadEDAPlaybooks logs a
visible Warn (not debug) for each loaded action playbook naming it and
stating it does not execute yet.
D5: ModuleRegistry.Invoke is deliberately schema-agnostic (the stored
invoker is type-erased and returns map[string]any). The map-to-Result
marshalling belongs in the coordinator named by the doc, which is the
t2db.31 run path and out of scope here.
Classifier enumeration (E) and verdict, all proven for a typed action
playbook via CEL (expr.NewEnv with a declared log.Result id):
unknown id CEL compile (undefined field) -> delete unknownActionReference
literal map index actions["x"] CEL compile (no _[_] overload) -> covered
computed index actions[key] CEL compile (undeclared 'key') -> covered
dynamic index actions[event.name] CEL compile (no _[_] overload) -> covered
"x" in actions CEL compile (no @in overload) -> covered
size(actions) CEL compile (no size overload) -> covered
actions.all(...) CEL compile (not a range) -> covered
actions == {} CEL compile (no _==_ overload) -> covered
bare actions compiles; KEPT classifier -> retained resolvable check
unknownActionReference is deleted; actionReferences/ActionReferences are
kept solely for the bare-actions spelling CEL does not reject.
Repo.BaseBranch() is where an empty base means "main", and the daemon
handed the raw field to worktree.Prepare -- the one call site that did,
beside the workflow step that passes the mapped value. A repository stored
with no base therefore reached git with "" and its branch was never cut
from main.
Reachable now because the document editor stopped prefilling base (its
per-path skeletons retired in 96abdc7c), which had been masking the missing
mapping rather than fixing it (archie-core-lwzd).
The guard is a wiring invariant in architecture_test.go: it walks the
package for the worktree.Prepare call and refuses the raw field, and fails
if the call is gone rather than passing unchecked.
A loaded playbook now decides a real task's workflow. The wiring point is the
daemon's definition pin (Daemon.resolveWorkflowID, consumed by
pinWorkflowFromCollection), not pollNATS/publishTask as the design doc
assumed: routing moved out of the agent process when workflow definitions
became database rows pinned before dispatch, so the pin is the one place a
task's workflow is chosen.
Precedence: an explicit Task.Workflow (the waiting_human -> approved requeue)
still wins, then a matching playbook, then workflow.ResolveWorkflowID's
existing label/kind bindings. A playbook naming an undefined workflow is a
reported failure that parks the task rather than a silent fall-through to the
binding's choice -- the operator bound that trigger deliberately.
Store.Dispatch returns the selected workflow name plus the matching playbook's
id and version, instead of a compiled workflow.Workflow: the production caller
decides against the active definition collection, and the id/version are the
first two components of the resolved gap-2 idempotency key. The playbook
package no longer imports internal/domain/workflow.
The shipped example's `when` read event.priority, a field no intake supplies,
so it could never have fired once wired. Both examples now read the event
surface playbookInput really builds, and label-trigger.yaml documents the axis
an instance defines for itself: trigger.kind is the closed workintake
vocabulary because a kind addresses a NATS subject, while trigger.labels is
free-form and binds an operator's own taxonomy to a workflow.
Module/Channel/Forge positions stay rejected at load; they need the
playbook_dispatches ledger first (archie-core-t2db.24).
Closes archie-core-t2db.23