Files
archie/internal/taskstate/taskstate.go
T
sam 1f2e7a42eb refactor: one definition of what approving or declining a task means
The dashboard and chat both let an operator approve or refuse work, and
they had drifted. Declining from the dashboard left the task
closed_wont_do; cancelling the same task from chat left it rejected. Two
operators looking at one queue saw different states for the same
decision, and "rejected" -- which reconcilePRs also uses for a pull
request closed without merging -- stopped meaning one thing.

internal/gateway deliberately does not import internal/store, so it kept
a hand-synced copy of the status strings with a comment asking future
editors to keep them aligned. That is the same defect one level down,
and it is how the drift happened.

internal/taskstate is a leaf package with no dependencies holding the
lifecycle vocabulary and the rules for operator actions. gateway, store
and the dashboard all import it, so gateway stays decoupled from store
without a copy, and CheckApprove/CheckRetry/CheckDecline have one
implementation. Declined is named for what it is -- a human said no --
and stays distinct from Rejected, which is something archie observed.

Chat cancel now records Declined. That is the behaviour change: same
decision, same state, whichever surface the operator used.

Rules were preserved rather than tidied while unifying. A parked task
still cannot be declined, which both surfaces already refused, even
though "not terminal" would have allowed it -- widening a rule under
cover of a refactor is how you ship a change nobody reviewed. The
comment says where to change it if that is ever wanted.

TestDashboardAndChatAgreeOnTerminalStates drives both real surfaces
against one store, so this cannot drift apart again without a red test.

Also removes a second rule for the dash-top-standalone class: renderSetup
already reconciles it from the data at the top of every call, and a later
branch cleared it again. Harmless, but it reads as two sources of truth
for one bit of layout state.
2026-08-05 04:15:39 +10:00

95 lines
3.6 KiB
Go

// Package taskstate owns the task lifecycle vocabulary and the rules for
// operator-initiated actions on a task.
//
// It exists because those rules had two implementations. The dashboard and
// chat both offer approve and reject, and they had drifted: rejecting from
// the dashboard left a task ClosedWontDo, cancelling the same task from chat
// left it Rejected. Two operators looking at the same queue saw different
// states for the same decision, and Rejected -- which the PR reconciler uses
// for "the pull request was closed without merging" -- no longer meant one
// thing.
//
// internal/gateway deliberately does not import internal/store, so it kept a
// hand-synced copy of the status strings with a comment asking future editors
// to keep them aligned. That is the same defect one level down. This package
// has no dependencies, so both can import it and the copy can go.
package taskstate
import "fmt"
// Task lifecycle statuses. The store persists these strings, so they are
// part of the on-disk format: renaming one is a migration, not a rename.
const (
Queued = "queued"
Running = "running"
WaitingHuman = "waiting_human"
PROpen = "pr_open"
Merged = "merged"
Parked = "parked"
Dead = "dead"
// Rejected means the forge closed the pull request without merging it.
// It is an outcome archie observed, not a decision an operator made --
// use Declined for that.
Rejected = "rejected"
// Declined means an operator refused the work. Whether they said so from
// the dashboard or from chat, the task lands here.
Declined = "closed_wont_do"
)
// Terminal reports whether a status is an end state, from which no further
// work happens without an operator asking for it.
func Terminal(status string) bool {
switch status {
case Merged, Rejected, Dead, Declined:
return true
default:
return false
}
}
// CheckApprove reports whether a task in this status can be approved.
//
// Approval releases work that is waiting on a human decision, so it is only
// meaningful from WaitingHuman. Approving anything else would either restart
// finished work or race a task that is already running.
func CheckApprove(status string) error {
if status != WaitingHuman {
return fmt.Errorf("task is %s, not awaiting approval", status)
}
return nil
}
// CheckRetry reports whether a task in this status can be retried.
//
// Only a parked task can be retried: parking is how archie says "this failed
// in a way a human might fix". A dead task has spent its retries and needs
// the cap raised or the work re-filed, not another attempt.
func CheckRetry(status string) error {
if status != Parked {
return fmt.Errorf("task is %s, not parked", status)
}
return nil
}
// CheckDecline reports whether a task in this status can be declined.
//
// Work that is still progressing can be declined -- including a running task,
// which is the case most worth being able to stop. Callers that can interrupt
// running work should do so before recording the state, or the task may write
// its own outcome afterwards and win.
//
// Parked is refused along with the terminal states. A parked task is not
// progressing, so there is nothing to stop; it is retried, or left. Both the
// dashboard and chat already behaved this way and this package preserves it
// rather than widening the rule while unifying it. If declining a parked task
// is ever wanted, change it here and both paths get it at once -- which is
// the point.
func CheckDecline(status string) error {
if Terminal(status) || status == Parked {
return fmt.Errorf("task is already %s", status)
}
return nil
}