Should channel answers be able to approve an irreversible action? #2093

Open
opened 2026-11-21 10:35:34 +00:00 by sam · 0 comments
Owner

#2072 requires a fresh passkey assertion to approve an irreversible action from the dashboard. A channel answer (a Telegram tap, say) is verified only by the channel identity mapped to a person, so the same action can still be approved from a channel without fresh authentication.

Options:

  • Leave channel approvals as they are. A channel identity is the factor.
  • Refuse channel approvals of irreversible actions, accepting denials only. The approver must open the dashboard to approve. This breaks the current Telegram-tap path for any action that doesn't declare itself recoverable, since an undeclared reversibility counts as irreversible.
  • Let a channel answer start a dashboard confirmation: the tap sends a link that opens the passkey ceremony for that request.

Done when: the maintainer has chosen, and the choice is filed as a feature or closed as no change.

#2072 requires a fresh passkey assertion to approve an irreversible action from the dashboard. A channel answer (a Telegram tap, say) is verified only by the channel identity mapped to a person, so the same action can still be approved from a channel without fresh authentication. Options: - Leave channel approvals as they are. A channel identity is the factor. - Refuse channel approvals of irreversible actions, accepting denials only. The approver must open the dashboard to approve. This breaks the current Telegram-tap path for any action that doesn't declare itself recoverable, since an undeclared reversibility counts as irreversible. - Let a channel answer start a dashboard confirmation: the tap sends a link that opens the passkey ceremony for that request. Done when: the maintainer has chosen, and the choice is filed as a feature or closed as no change.
sam added the decisionmedium labels 2026-11-21 10:35:34 +00:00
Sign in to join this conversation.
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: sam/archie#2093