Infra decoded real tokens from both clients, and two of the three facts changed
this code.
A machine token carries NO sub at all: it names its caller by client_id, and the
identity is that client. A person's token carries sub, the provider's stable
identifier for the person. The subject is now derived explicitly -- sub when
present, else client_id -- and a verified token asserting neither is refused
rather than accepted as an anonymous caller, because accepting it would let any
token the provider ever signed act as whoever the binding happened to hold. A
machine identity is therefore per client registration, one identity per client,
which is what makes per-agent identity a configuration decision rather than a code
change.
Scopes are read from either claim shape. The standard is a space-delimited scope
string and this provider also emits an scp array; reading only one shape yields no
scopes at all, which is worse than reading none deliberately.
The audience-at-authorisation-endpoint trap is pinned by a test: a token minted
without the requested audience arrives with aud empty, and the audience check
refuses it. That refusal is correct and the fix is the request the human flow
builds, not a weaker check here -- a test now fails if anyone weakens it.
The PRD records both as constraints: a person's client and an agent's client are
registered separately because a shared registration collapses the distinction the
attribution rests on, and a person's token requests the audience at the
authorisation endpoint as well as the token endpoint.
Verified: task check exit 0; internal/infrastructure/oidc passes, including
subject derivation for both token shapes and every refusal.
One identity record covers users, agents, external agents, service accounts and the
system. Authentication is delegated to the estate's OIDC provider and attribution
stays archie's. Nothing that verifies a credential, issues a session, stores a
password or checks a permission is built here, per Sam's hard requirement that
authentication and authorisation are OSS archie integrates.
Authelia is the only provider, because the estate already runs it in front of the
dashboard and it issues credentials for both kinds of caller: authorization code
for humans and client_credentials for machines, whose subject is the client's own
identifier. Each agent is its own client, so two agents are distinguishable in the
audit trail and revocable separately. SPIFFE/SPIRE is rejected on operational fit
rather than quality: it is adopted and its attestation is strictly stronger, but it
adds a control plane archie does not have and answers a threat archie does not face
while its agents run in containers the operator launches.
internal/domain/identity survives and is not replaced by the provider's directory,
because it carries what the directory does not: lifecycle, bindings and
attribution. archie owns the subject binding that ties an identity to the provider
subject asserting it -- the same bridge identity_aliases already provides from a
legacy name -- plus the lifecycle, the attribution and the identity audit trail. It
owns no credential, password, session, token, signing key or permission rule.
How an agent proves who it is: it presents a token the provider issued to its own
client, archie validates it against the provider's published keys and takes the
subject as the acting identity, so an agent holds the secret and archie holds only
public keys. A WebMCP tool call cannot be a proof of agent identity and cannot be
made one -- a page can invoke its own tools, so an agent's call and a page script's
call arrive identically and the difference does not exist on the wire. It is
attributed to the identity the request presented with its source as a hint, and it
never records that an agent acted or that a human approved. Agent-initiated action
therefore arrives on a surface that carries a credential.
Task actions gain both attributions: the acting identity, derived from the
credential and never from a supplied string, and the authorising principal whose
authority the action used. The event kind describes the actor, so
KindHumanApproved is recorded only when a human acted; an agent acting under a
standing approval records itself as actor and the human as authorising principal.
An action with no authorising principal is unattributed rather than attributed to
the actor's own authority, and the review gate's approver is the approval's
authorising principal, not the surface they used.
External agents are first-class: the same record, kind service_account, bound to
its own provider client, at the cost of a client registration and a secret to
rotate per peer. Authorisation is deferred: no engine, no policy language, no
decision point, with the credential's scopes as the only input; the decision point
goes behind a single archie interface when per-skill limits are needed.
The PRD is a development-audience page, so it regenerates dev-docs.json to 69
pages. Verified: task check exit 0, including docs:prds.