Commit Graph
2 Commits
Author SHA1 Message Date
sam e7e5ddfba5 fix(statestore): make validate run boot's gate, and stop backup replacing the database
Two P1 findings from review, both about a claim outrunning the code.

validate answered a different question from boot's. Boot refuses on
configuration.Validate over the file config with every stored resource
layered onto it (internal/app/archied/control_plane.go:27), which is a
stricter check than the write path's per-resource Decode: validateScheduling
never inspects dispatch.trigger and explicitly permits "0s", while boot
rejects an unknown trigger and a non-positive poll interval. A store holding
such a value printed "is a valid store ... N stored resources validate" and
exited 0 while archied exited 1 on it -- a false green pushing an operator
toward the blunt restore instead of the surgical rollback.

validate now runs both layers and reports both, in boot's order:
store.ValidateFile, then the write path's ValidateStored, then the config
gate. The layering itself is now one implementation: controlplane's
runtimeConfigFrom takes a resourceReader, which the gRPC client and a new
Server.StoredRuntimeConfig (reading its own store) both provide, so the
offline check cannot drift from the daemon's. validate takes -config /
-config-overlay (default: the path the serve subcommand uses), because the
question is about the stored values layered onto that document.

backup had no guard against -out naming the database. It renames its
snapshot over the target, so `backup -db F -out F` replaced a database a
serving State Store may still have open and orphaned the WAL of the file it
just unlinked -- the state Restore refuses up front and maintenance.go's own
comment calls unrecoverable. backup now refuses with the same message
Restore uses, which is what makes its exemption from the ownership lock
sound.

Claims corrected where they ran ahead of the code: ValidateStored now says it
is the write path's check and not boot's, the Restore comment no longer
promises "never a mixture" for the sidecars it removes first, the usage text
advertises validate's -config, and the architecture table drops "must be
stopped" for validate (nothing enforces it; read-only opens skip the lock by
design) and states which two layers validate reports.

Tests: TestRecoveryValidateRunsTheGateBootRuns fails on the pre-fix code
("validate accepted a stored policy the daemon refuses to boot with") and
covers a store the State Store never seeded; TestRecoveryBackupRefuses-
TheDatabaseAsItsOwnSnapshot fails on the pre-fix code ("backup over the
database itself succeeded"). The validate-accept test now seeds the store
through ImportConfig and asserts the reported count is non-zero, and the
stored-resource case uses a value both gates refuse instead of one only the
write path does.
2026-09-21 22:04:42 +10:00
sam b8b477fb32 feat(statestore): offline backup, restore, validate and rollback
archie-state-store gains the offline recovery commands
docs/prds/runtime-control-plane.md ("Bootstrap, migration, and recovery")
asks for. They work on the task database file directly -- <db_path>-tasks.sqlite,
not db_path -- and need neither archied nor the Web UI, which matters because
the failure they exist for is the one that stops archied starting:

  backup   -db F -out F     consistent snapshot (VACUUM INTO), verified as a
                            usable store before it is published; safe against
                            a serving store
  restore  -db F -from F    replace the database with a snapshot, dropping the
                            replaced file's -wal/-shm
  validate -db F            readable, not corrupt, schema no newer than this
                            binary, every stored resource decoding under the
                            definition that owns it
  rollback -db F -kind K    replay an earlier revision of a stored resource
           [-revision N]    through the ordinary replace, recorded as a new
                            revision

No rollback RPC is added and none is needed: a revision carries its own value,
so restoring one is the same replace the dashboard and the channels already
use, by hand, with the store stopped.

"The State Store is stopped" is checked rather than assumed. The serving
process now takes an exclusive flock on <db>.lock for its whole life
(store.AcquireOwnership), and restore/rollback refuse with
`task database is owned by another process` while it holds it. backup is the
deliberate exception: the update installer runs inside the process it is
replacing and cannot stop the State Store.

scripts/archie-update-install takes its pre-flight snapshot through
`go run ./cmd/archie-state-store backup` from the release being installed
instead of its own sqlite3 shell, so the installer and an operator run one
implementation. The watchdog's refusal semantics are unchanged: an update that
cannot back up still must not start.

Docs: safe-change-and-recovery.md's "Recovery: not yet built" now describes
what exists.
2026-09-21 22:04:41 +10:00