The fix-closure review found the previous pass moved the failure instead of
ending it. A seed the resource validator refuses leaves the kind ABSENT, and
RuntimeConfig treated an absent kind as fatal, so archied and the Gateway
refused to start with "control-plane resource not found" -- a database-named
error that editing config.toml cannot clear. Reproduced before the fix: every
kind in the new table failed that way.
Two changes, one on each side of the seam:
- Client.RuntimeConfig (and RuntimeChatConfig) now treat a kind with no stored
value as "the file document's value stays in effect", which is what the
skip-and-report comment already claimed. The version map records no version
for such a kind, so nothing is reported as applied. A value the file layer
also refuses still fails closed, at configuration.Validate, with a message
naming the file's own field -- and the file is the fix.
- Which repository lists are valid can no longer differ between the layers.
configuration.ValidateRepositories is now the single rule set (owner and name
present, no duplicates, compilable test glob) and the repository-policies
resource validator delegates to it. The file layer had no duplicate rule
while the resource layer did, so a duplicate [[repos]] entry passed the loader
and then vanished into a skipped seed.
Also, from the same review: the scheduling validator's "0s" carve-out is gone,
so a zero poll interval is refused at write time as configuration.Validate
refuses it (there is no defaulting behind a stored value); applyOverlayFile's
doc now says which overlay forms fold (a conf.d extra does not, and nothing
reads cfg.Extra); and plugin-settings' no-op validator is a named function with
the reason it accepts everything.
Review of the two previous commits found the split was incomplete in both
directions: the checks moved off the file load path were still enforced
anywhere the value could enter the system, and the fold reached only one of the
three overlay paths.
A stale database-owned TOML value could still stop archie-state-store. The
process seeds every control-plane resource from the same file config on a fresh
database, and the seed runs the resource's own validator; three of the five
values the loader now accepts aborted the boot there (verified by booting
RunStateStore before the fix). A seed that does not validate is now SKIPPED and
reported instead of fatal: the resource stays absent, so the file's value is the
one in effect and editing config.toml is still the fix -- the daemon and the
Gateway are where it fails closed, at boot.runtimeConfig.
The resource validators were weaker than configuration.Validate for exactly the
fields the split reclassified, so a value the file path used to refuse at load
became storable in the database, and then un-fixable by editing config.toml.
The trigger enum and the test-glob rule now come from the configuration package
rather than being restated, the container image is required there as it is in the
file, and a table test ties the two layers together value by value.
The directory form of -config-overlay kept the archie-core-e2e2 failure: it
decoded each overlay file straight into the populated config, so a map-valued
entry it only partly addressed still cleared the fields it did not name. Both
the overlay layer's main file and its feature files now fold, which is what
Loader.Dir's documented parity with Loader.Overlay has always claimed.
The overlay file's key report is derived from the apply's own view of the file as
well as the file decode's, because TOML matches keys case-insensitively and the
fold's yaml decode does not: a key only the file decode matched was consumed by
the report and dropped by the apply, a silent no-op that worked in the base file.
Tests: the state-store boot is asserted against the real process, the directory
overlay and the case-mismatched key each have one, and ImportConfig pins that a
refused seed is not stored.
Loader.finalize ran the whole validation over the file document, so a stale
TOML value in a setting the control plane owns failed startup -- including
archie-state-store, which resolves its file config and opens the store without
ever layering a database resource over it. docs/prds/runtime-control-plane.md,
"Bootstrap, migration, and recovery": after migration, settings in TOML are
ignored and cannot block State Store startup.
The checks over the settings a control plane resource is seeded from and
replaces wholesale now run only on the effective document: providers
(provider-settings), poll_interval and dispatch (scheduling-policy), containers
(container-runtime-policies) and the repository lists (repository-policies).
They moved from validate to validateDatabaseOwned; validateBootstrap keeps the
checks over settings no resource carries (forge intake, identities, nats,
memory, image, capture). File sources pass validateBootstrap and
Loader.ApplyOverlay, which layers overrides onto an effective document, passes
Validate.
Nothing stops being judged: the daemon and the Gateway both run the full
Validate in boot.runtimeConfig, the one place database resources are layered
in, before any capability starts -- so a stored value that will not validate
still stops the process rather than being published. Cases that asserted the
load path rejects a database-owned value now assert both layers, and
TestRuntimeConfigFailsClosedOnAnInvalidDatabaseValue pins the second.