The playbook engine PRD had grown to 972 lines against CLAUDE.md's one-page
bar, because four documents were living in it.
The expression decision was the worst of it: an H2 nested inside a numbered
list item, 270 lines with twelve H3s and its own Status and Date fields. That
broke the outline and gave the document a second, non-canonical status. It is
now docs/prds/playbook-expression-syntax.md, named flat and linked by a Parent
field the way module-position.md already relates to this epic. The parent
keeps the decision and a pointer.
Repetition, against the state-each-fact-once rule: reject-at-load was stated
ten times, the plugin engine rule nine, producer-only seven. The producer-only
argument ran 32 lines and closed by restating itself; it is eight lines and
stated once. One heading read "confirmed non-issue (stated once)" above the
third statement of the point.
Open question 3 was closed by module-position.md and still listed here as
open. The section holding four decisions and one note is no longer called
"Open questions", and the note is a standing constraint, which is what it is.
Also removed: two list summaries written before their lists, ten dated
attributions, two progress claims, three orphan line citations, and the
undefined { Call: ... } notation.
Five findings in other PRDs came from tightening the guard, not from this
split.
Three defects the first sweep left behind, each caught by a rule the guard
did not yet have.
Statuses. RULES.md gives three; the tree had 25 values, and the free-text ones
were carrying progress. "Implemented (wiring landed)" and "Ratified (rev. 2e).
Rev. 2e adds the OpenTaskByPR lookup. Rev. 2d revised section 10..." were both
changelogs living in the one field the other rules exempt. Every PRD now
declares Draft, Approved or Finalised and nothing else; five that declared
nothing now declare one. A revision number moves to **Revision:**, a pointer
to the authoritative document to **Authority:**, and what a past revision
changed to git. CLAUDE.md's citation of state-store-contract rev. 2e still
resolves.
Stale cross-references. "Supersedes the 2026-09-03 open question", "this
bullet previously said", "an earlier draft of this document claimed" all point
at text the reader cannot see, because it was replaced. A supersede marker
survives only when it names a file, a section or a symbol that can be found.
Temporal hedges. 100 uses of today, currently and right now across 31 files.
Each dates its sentence to the day it was written: "[notify] today is one
webhook URL, read in one place" stops being true the moment this design lands,
while still reading as the premise it rests on.
The header-field exemption was also too wide. "**Date:** 2026-09-03, Channel
resolved 2026-09-22" smuggled a dated status into the one line the rules did
not read; the exemption is now a Date holding only a date and a Status holding
only one of the three.
183 findings across 28 of 46 PRDs, of which 150 were file:line citations. Two
were already hard-broken: one named a file that no longer exists, one pointed
past the end of its file. The rest resolved to a line that still exists,
which is the worse failure -- a citation that silently drifted onto unrelated
code still reads as authoritative.
Citations now name the file and the symbol. Dated status markers become the
decision they carried ("Status 2026-09-05: resolved" -> "Resolved"), since
whether a question is answered is design information and when it was answered
is not. Progress inventories become scope statements: mcp-tool-completion now
fences what is out of scope rather than reporting what shipped.
status-health-surface drops phase-completion from its headings and keeps the
rule that earned them, that a reported field must have a truthful source.
eda-playbook-engine.md was the worst file and my own t2db.23 status block was
part of why; it is rewritten as the resolution it records.
A loaded playbook now decides a real task's workflow. The wiring point is the
daemon's definition pin (Daemon.resolveWorkflowID, consumed by
pinWorkflowFromCollection), not pollNATS/publishTask as the design doc
assumed: routing moved out of the agent process when workflow definitions
became database rows pinned before dispatch, so the pin is the one place a
task's workflow is chosen.
Precedence: an explicit Task.Workflow (the waiting_human -> approved requeue)
still wins, then a matching playbook, then workflow.ResolveWorkflowID's
existing label/kind bindings. A playbook naming an undefined workflow is a
reported failure that parks the task rather than a silent fall-through to the
binding's choice -- the operator bound that trigger deliberately.
Store.Dispatch returns the selected workflow name plus the matching playbook's
id and version, instead of a compiled workflow.Workflow: the production caller
decides against the active definition collection, and the id/version are the
first two components of the resolved gap-2 idempotency key. The playbook
package no longer imports internal/domain/workflow.
The shipped example's `when` read event.priority, a field no intake supplies,
so it could never have fired once wired. Both examples now read the event
surface playbookInput really builds, and label-trigger.yaml documents the axis
an instance defines for itself: trigger.kind is the closed workintake
vocabulary because a kind addresses a NATS subject, while trigger.labels is
free-form and binds an operator's own taxonomy to a workflow.
Module/Channel/Forge positions stay rejected at load; they need the
playbook_dispatches ledger first (archie-core-t2db.24).
Closes archie-core-t2db.23
Decision for channel/forge/module action keying in eda-playbook-engine.md:
one durable dedup record per (action, event) pair via a playbook_dispatches
ledger in internal/store, reusing binding_dispatches' INSERT OR IGNORE +
sentinel conventions, with record-before-invoke ordering (at-most-once, the
reverse of the binding loop's ordering, justified by the external-side-effect
harm profile). Key = (playbook_id, playbook_version, event_id, action_id):
event_id is the TaskEnvelope.IdempotencyKey() value already carried on
DispatchInput.TaskID; the key is a fixed structural composition, deliberately
not a CEL expression (event stays dyn; determinism under redelivery is the
binding constraint). Redelivery of a recorded action skips it and continues
the run at debug level, never surfaced as an error. Rows live as long as the
playbook exists, no time-based expiry.
Extends event-sources-and-reactions.md's contract without contradicting it:
PublishUnique's dedup is publish-path only (Nats-Msg-Id + 2-minute
DedupWindow), so consumer redelivery of side-effecting reactions was never
covered; the ledger adds exactly that consumer-side piece, reusing the
TaskEnvelope identity and the typed-family shape. The gap-2 prerequisites
(Playbook ID/Version, DispatchInput.TaskID) already landed in a4a8ae7.
Documentation only: no code changes. Keying implementation is separate
follow-up work.
Refs: archie-core-t2db.17
Resolves archie-core-t2db.18. States stop-on-first-failure as the
committed default when a playbook action fails mid-run, grounded in
workflow.Run's three-way stage-failure distinction
(internal/domain/workflow/workflow.go:294, 317-336) and the t2db.9-12
load-collision drop-and-report rule (eda-playbook-engine.md:155-159),
with explicit reasoning why the default does not violate
event-sources-and-reactions.md's producer-only rule. Gap 2 (execution-time
idempotency) remains open. Documentation only; no code changes.
Drafted for archie-core-t2db.17 (idempotency) and .18 (mid-run
failure), following the same evidence-then-sign-off process the CEL
resolution used -- explicitly marked PROPOSED, not decided, pending
Sam's approval. Every claim checked against the real shipped code
during drafting, not assumed, catching two wrong assumptions before
they landed:
- Gap 1 (mid-run failure): proposes reusing workflow.Run's existing
three-way distinction (real error -> stop+report; shutdown
interruption -> not a failure; no-outcome -> definition-bug parked)
rather than inventing new semantics. States the producer-only
boundary and the J3 (condition-error) vs action-failure distinction
explicitly, and states plainly that rollback is not attempted.
- Gap 2 (idempotency): proposes reusing internal/store/bindings.go's
binding_dispatches at-most-once ledger shape (INSERT OR IGNORE +
sentinel error) rather than a new mechanism. Caught two real gaps
while drafting, both stated honestly rather than glossed over: (1)
t2db.15's shipped Playbook struct has no ID/Version to key a ledger
on -- Binding gets its identity from being a DB row, a playbook is
just a loaded file; (2) DispatchInput is a task-label trigger (same
vocabulary as workflow.Route()), NOT a webhook-capture trigger --
captured_events.id, the first instinct, does not apply to what
shipped, and DispatchInput doesn't yet carry any task identity to
key on either. Both are named as concrete prerequisites for whoever
implements this, not silently assumed solved.
Not marked as settled -- the status lines say "awaiting Sam's sign-off"
explicitly, matching the process this doc already used for the CEL
decision.
Seventh slice of docs/prds/eda-playbook-engine.md (t2db.15), consuming
t2db.14's expr package: the rich trigger+actions playbook document and
the coordinator that dispatches it.
- internal/domain/eda/playbook: Load(dir) reads *.yaml/*.yml playbook
documents (trigger + exactly one workflow-kind action + optional CEL
when), validating the HARD BOUNDARY at load: a playbook with 2+ actions
or a non-workflow action position is a reported load failure --
multi-action and Module/Channel/Forge actions stay blocked on the
unresolved execution-time gaps. Any malformed YAML, invalid trigger,
missing workflow name, or when compile failure fails the WHOLE load
(reject-at-load, same shape as routing collisions); a missing dir is an
empty store. Trigger reuses the existing workintake kind/label
vocabulary (no second label-matching mechanism). Dispatch matches
trigger, evaluates when (CEL, event context with actions: {} -- no
prior actions in single-action playbooks), and returns the named
workflow from the registry via the same lookup Route() uses -- no
duplicated dispatch logic. when eval error follows the resolved doc's
J3: false, skip, caller logs.
- Store.Dispatch(reg, DispatchInput) is the coordinator entrypoint; input
carries Labels/Kind/Event. Production task intake wiring
(daemon.go/pollNATS/publishTask) is explicitly NOT in this ticket -- a
follow-up; proven end to end via direct tests plus the shipped example
(examples/eda-playbooks/bug-tdd.yaml) loaded and dispatched through the
real path.
- Config: EDAPlaybookDir (eda_playbook_dir), documented as DISTINCT from
PlaybookDirs (flat binding files) -- a reader cannot confuse the two.
- Bootstrap: playbook.Load wired in loadWorkflows, log-and-abort on
failure matching every prior slice; nonexistent dir is an empty store.
- workflow.Route(), workflowForLabels, and the t2db.9-.12 binding loaders
are UNTOUCHED (verified: their full test suites pass, zero regressions).
Also carries small lint cleanups on t2db.13/.14 code flagged by the gate
run: expr Eval no longer type-asserts to ref.Val (Eval returns ref.Val
directly in v0.32.0; cel-go's own Eval wraps evaluation in recover --
verified in source); module decodeLogArgs extracted to clear the nestif
finding. golangci-lint: 0 issues.
Tests (10): single-action round trip, when-false skip, 2-action load
failure, non-workflow position load failure, when compile failure drops
playbook, empty trigger load failure, trigger mismatch skip, no-when
match, one-invalid-file fails whole load, missing dir empty store, plus
the shipped example load+dispatch. task check clean (113/113 UI, exit 0).
CEL (cel.dev/cel-go, pinned v0.32.0) is the single expression mechanism
covering both an action's `when` condition and its `args` values,
evaluated against a read-only context (`event`, `actions.<id>.result`).
Rejects the custom-gate precedent (Yaegi-in-YAML) as inverting the
design's own "YAML is data, Yaegi is logic" premise. Expressions
compile/type-check at playbook load, consistent with the existing
collision-handling reject-at-load rule; generated Module Result schemas
become CEL type declarations so result-path typos reject at load too.
Vetted against expr-lang/expr, gval, govaluate (archived), starlark-go:
CEL wins on structural safety (non-Turing-complete, CostLimit-bounded,
error values not panics, zero security advisories on record) despite
the largest binary cost (+13MB) of the candidates -- accepted because
the alternative is re-implementing CEL's type-checker on a bespoke
grammar for the same guarantee.
Sign-off (Sam, 2026-09-03): all judgment calls (J1-J5) accepted as
proposed, including J2's per-value CEL-literal quoting cost and the
+13MB binary size trade.
Cross-references in module-position.md updated to point at this
resolution instead of citing open question 1 as unresolved.
Resolves eda-playbook-engine.md's deferred schema-generation question
for the Module action position. Generalizes the fixed-signature,
resolved-by-name Yaegi pattern already shipped three times (custom
gate, workflow stage plugins, skill plugins) instead of inventing a
new mechanism: one small hand-written schema package per action kind,
go:generate yaegi extract (the same command wfextract/gateextract
already use) producing its symbol table, a ModuleRegistry keyed by
kind rather than a generic any-typed Module interface -- keeping every
position individually compliant with the plugin engine rule instead
of reopening the generic-hook question event-sources-and-reactions.md
already closed.
Closes open question 3 (trust boundary: operator-installed, in-process,
same tier as PluginDir/SecretEngineDir -- not repository-supplied task
code). Recommends a side-effect-free first Module kind, since any kind
with a real external effect is still blocked on the parent doc's
unresolved execution-time gaps (idempotency, mid-run failure).
Fourth slice of docs/prds/eda-playbook-engine.md (t2db.12): the design
doc's pre-merge collision layer, as a gopls-shaped standalone binary
(cmd/archie-playbooks) rather than a Taskfile wrapper -- one binary, one
schema source, mode-based entrypoints.
- cmd/archie-playbooks: subcommand dispatch table from day one (lint now;
an lsp/serve mode later slots in without restructuring), flag parsing
only per organisation.md's cmd/ rule.
- internal/app/archieplaybooks: the lint mode's composition -- collects
directories, calls workflow.LoadPlaybookDirs (the daemon's own loader),
reports findings. No second validation path: the linter agrees with
runtime startup validation by construction.
- Reuses LoadKindWorkflowsYAML/LoadLabelWorkflowsYAML/LoadPlaybookDirs
directly; collision/malformed/invalid bindings exit non-zero.
- Known limitation recorded: findings are file-granular, not
line-granular (yaml.Unmarshal into map discards line numbers; a
file:line diagnostic needs a yaml.Node upgrade, out of scope here).
- Taskfile lint:playbooks target; PRD records the shipped shape and the
file-granular caveat.
Not a bundled-vs-standalone tradeoff: validation logic lives in
internal/domain/workflow with no knowledge of its caller, so archied
and agents already validate in-process, and the standalone cmd/
binary (t2db.12) exists only because CI/editors are out-of-process
consumers by nature. One implementation, two thin consumer shapes.
Third slice of docs/prds/eda-playbook-engine.md (t2db.11), completing open
question 2: instead of a single playbook dir, the config gains a LIST of
directories (playbook_dirs) of *.yaml/*.yml binding files, loaded at
startup as an additional input to workflow_routing_file and
workflow_labels_file, which remain supported unchanged.
- LoadPlaybookDirs(dirs []string) reads every yaml file across the
configured directories and merges kind + arbitrary-label bindings.
- This is what finally exercises the design doc's drop-and-report
collision rule: a single file cannot collide with itself, so the
cross-source path (two files in one dir, two dirs, or a dir plus a
single-file field) had never run in production. A binding key declared
by more than one source is a reported load failure, not a silent
pick-one by source order or version.
- Router-level collision handling: MergeKindWorkflows/MergeLabelWorkflows
fail on a key bound by both the single-file fields and the playbook
dirs, applied at boot.
- Config: PlaybookDirs []string, empty by default (no behavior change for
existing configs). Repo-scoping (typing dirs to Config.Repos owner/name)
is explicitly deferred to a separate later decision per ticket;
org/tenant keying is out of scope.
- PRD: records the list shape per Sam's correction (single dir would
contradict multiple independently-maintained playbook sources).
Second slice of docs/prds/eda-playbook-engine.md, complementing the
kind->workflow layer (WorkflowRoutingFile): the label vocabulary itself
becomes playbook data. A label outside the closed bug/feature/bootstrap
kind set (e.g. security) now dispatches to a registered workflow from an
optional WorkflowLabelsFile, instead of falling through to triage.
- LabelWorkflows + LoadLabelWorkflowsYAML/SetLabelWorkflows in
internal/domain/workflow/routing.go, mirroring the kind layer's
once-at-startup lifecycle. The closed Kind/NATS-subject set is
untouched; the map only extends binding authority for labels the kind
layer does not own.
- Collision rule per design doc: a label owned by the kind set, an empty
label, an empty workflow name, or a duplicate binding is a reported
load failure (dropped, logged, error returned to the caller) -- the
schema defines what is accepted; nothing is silently arbitrated by
schema/version.
- Route() precedence: explicit t.Workflow -> arbitrary-label binding ->
kind binding -> triage -> implement -> default.
- Config: WorkflowLabelsFile (workflow_labels_file), wired at boot
alongside WorkflowRoutingFile; documented in config.example.toml.
- PRD: records this slice's decisions (single-file shape, collision rule,
precedence) so later slices stay anchored.
Records the design for drop-in, data-driven workflows/labels/actions:
YAML playbooks as pure orchestration data over four typed logic
positions (Workflow/Module/Channel/Forge), go:generate-driven schemas,
and load-time collision handling (detect+log+report, no auto-arbitration).
Flags execution-time idempotency and mid-run failure handling as
unresolved gaps to close before Channel/Forge or multi-action playbooks
ship.