97 -> 85. Not one of the eleven nilerr findings was a bug.
I called these "real bug candidates" when I planned the phases. I was
wrong, and the reason is worth recording: every site is the same
deliberate idiom, and a linter cannot see intent.
- inprocess.go (5) and gateway.go (2) are handlers that report a
problem as TEXT to their consumer. A tool handler returning a Go
error aborts the tool call; returning "rejected: ..." lets the model
read the feedback and retry with valid arguments. A chat handler
returning a Go error surfaces as a gateway fault instead of a usage
hint to the human.
- worker.go carries runErr in the response envelope's Error field.
Returning it as a Go error too would double-report and abort the
NATS reply.
- email.go returns nil when Accept fails because context cancellation
closed the listener. That is a clean shutdown.
- codesearch.go skips an unreadable entry and continues the walk. A
best-effort index must not abort on one bad file.
- skill.go is documented in the function comment already: a
non-directory skills path means "no skills", not a fatal error.
Annotated each with //nolint:nilerr and the specific reason rather than
excluding the linter by path, so nilerr stays live everywhere else and
the next reader wondering "why nil here?" gets an answer at the site.
This is the phase I insisted on keeping single-session and out of the
subagent fan-out. A worker told to "fix nilerr" would have converted all
eleven to error returns: malformed tool arguments would hard-fail the
agent loop instead of being correctable, chat typos would read as
gateway faults, and shutdown would log spurious errors. Every test would
still have passed.
Checkpoint commit covering concurrent work across several archie-core-abg
epics to avoid losing in-progress state:
- Memory manager (18.7-18.16): background sync pipeline, prefetch with
timeout, memory-write notification, threat scanning, shutdown drain
with abandoned-write tracking, frozen snapshot pattern. Wired
ScanContent and NotifyMemoryToolWrite into HandleToolCall so scanning
and notification actually apply to writes, not just exist as unused
primitives.
- Fixed a literal unresolved merge-conflict that had been committed to
internal/memory/scrubber/scrubber.go.
- Tool provider/registry, MCP client/transport (stdio, HTTP, SSE),
multimodal results, disclosure.
- Pairing device auth store, rate limiting.
- Gateway compression, session store, tasks.
- Various workflow, plugin host, and agentexec updates.
- Introduce `-config-overlay` flag and `config.LoadOverlay()` to merge a base config with an overlay file, only overriding fields the overlay sets. This enables docker-compose to mount the base config from the host and apply only deployment-specific overrides.
- Create `internal/natsrpc` package with reusable NATS request/reply primitives (Envelope, Client, Call, RegisterAll, Respond). Migrate storerpc, worktreerpc, and forgerpc to use it, eliminating duplicated marshal/unmarshal and error handling.
- Create `internal/yaegiutil` package with shared interpreter construction (stdlib + extra symbols), generic export resolution (Resolve), and panic recovery (Safe). Migrate all Yaegi-based surfaces (gate scripts, daemon plugins, skill plugins, workflow stages, skill scripts) to use it, reducing boilerplate and centralizing panic safety.
- Simplify `config.docker.toml` to contain only overlay fields (paths, container config) and remove the duplicated repos list – the base config is now the single source of truth.
- Update docker-compose.yml to pass both -config and -config-overlay flags and mount the base config from the host.
- Add tests for LoadOverlay, DockerConfigOverlaysExampleConfig, Envelope, and yaegiutil utilities.
P1 (panic): nil Storage guard in daemon.process()
C1 (correctness): check WriteTaskJSON error — don't start blind
C2 (correctness): move 'working' label after container setup
C3 (correctness): warn on duplicate workflow names in registry
C4 (correctness): test that generated _Plugin wrapper has nil-guards
C5 (correctness): .agents/skills as file (ENOTDIR) not fatal
C6 (correctness): ecosystem case-insensitive in cacheMounts
N1 (correctness): TOCTOU race — treat 'already exists' as success
N2 (correctness): recover from panicking plugin.Name() at startup
--- Details ---
P1: d.Storage.Setup() is now guarded by a nil check. In normal
operation Storage is always set when ContainerPool is set, but
the invariant is now explicit and enforced.
C1: container.WriteTaskJSON() error was discarded with _. Now it
returns early with a park transition — the container never starts
without a boot-time brief.
C2: SetStateLabel('working') was called before container setup.
If Acquire failed, the task was parked but the label stayed
'working' permanently. Now the label is set only after successful
container setup (or immediately if no containers are configured).
C3: BuildRegistry and AugmentRegistry now log a warning when two
skills declare the same workflow name and one overwrites the other.
C4: TestGeneratedWrapperHasNilGuards verifies that nil WName/
WVersion don't panic. If go generate strips the nil-guards, this
test catches it before the daemon crashes.
C5: skill.Catalog() now returns nil (no skills) instead of
propagating ENOTDIR errors when .agents/skills is a file.
C6: cacheMounts() normalizes ecosystem to lowercase. 'Python',
'NODE', 'Go' all resolve correctly now.
N1: ensureVolume() treats Docker's 'already exists' error as
success, closing the TOCTOU window between VolumeInspect and
VolumeCreate.
N2: safePluginInfo() wraps plugin.Name()/Version() calls in a
recover. A plugin with a panicking Name() no longer crashes the
daemon at startup.
Skills now declare their workflow in metadata.archie.workflow.
Catalog() scans frontmatter only (lazy, Tier 1). SkillForWorkflow()
derives the skill directory from the catalog — no hardcoded maps.
Removed workflowToSkill map (agent.go) and workflowToSkillDir switch
(worker.go). Both daemon and agent use the same catalog-based lookup.
Skills renamed to archie-wf-* convention. SKILL.md files updated with
workflow metadata field.
Progressive disclosure Tier 1: Catalog() returns name+description
+workflow. Tier 2: LoadBody() loads full body on activation.
Gap 8 (frontmatter plugins key): add Plugins []string to
Metadata.Archie struct. Parses the plugins list from SKILL.md
YAML frontmatter per PRD section 5.
Gap 2 (grace period): add GracePeriod field to container.Config,
distinct from MaxUptime. MaxUptime = total container lifetime cap.
GracePeriod = idle time after task completion before kill.
Documented per PRD sections 1 and 4.
Gap 6 (task.json): add TaskPayload struct and WriteTaskJSON
function to internal/container. Daemon writes the task payload
to <workspace>/task.json before container start, matching the
PRD section 3 /data/task.json boot brief.
Adds plugin discovery to internal/skill — Yaegi .go files in a skill's
plugins/ directory are loaded alongside the SKILL.md body.
- Plugin type: Name, Path, Src, Run(input) (string, error) via Yaegi
- DiscoverPlugins(dir, skillName): scans .agents/skills/<name>/plugins/*.go
- Run() uses Yaegi interpreter with full stdlib access; plugins must use
package main and export func Run(string) string
- Discover() now populates Skill.Plugins alongside frontmatter + body
- Missing plugins/ dir returns empty slice (not an error)
- Missing skill returns nil (not an error)
5 new tests: DiscoverPlugins, DiscoverPluginsNone,
DiscoverPluginsMissingSkill, PluginRun (Yaegi round-trip),
DiscoverIncludesPlugins (integration with Discover).
Adds internal/skill package with YAML frontmatter parsing and skill
discovery from .agents/skills/ (agentskills.io spec convention).
- Frontmatter struct with name, description, version, metadata.archie
- Parse() extracts YAML frontmatter delimited by --- markers
- Discover() scans .agents/skills/*/SKILL.md (follows wfeval pattern)
- LoadBody() for single-skill lazy loading
Skills moved from .archie/skills/ to .agents/skills/ per the
agentskills.io specification.
Wiring: TaskContext.SkillBody field, lazy-loaded on first agent stage
from worktree. When non-empty, prepended to Mission as "Follow these
project-specific guidelines" context. Hardcoded Mission templates stay
(task-specific formatting). Backward compatible: empty when no skill
found.