Applies the four-reviewer pass over the forge/dashboard-actions work.
The through-line is that several capabilities were wired but inert, and
one of them could cost real work.
DUPLICATE WORK. "Closes #N" was dropped from PR bodies in favour of
LinkBranch, which is sidebar linkage on Gitea and a no-op stub on
GitHub -- neither closes anything, and nothing else did either. So a
merged task left its issue open, labelled and assigned; the next poll
re-enqueued it, and once the dashboard's Clear removed the task row that
became a second implementation and a second PR for work already merged.
reconcilePRs now closes the issue on merge, and a rejected task closes
its issue too. A PR closed without merging deliberately leaves the issue
open: that usually means "try again".
MAX RETRIES. Configured, defaulted and reported by /api/config, and
enforced nowhere -- markDead was unreachable and EffectiveMaxRetries had
no callers, so the dashboard's retry incremented retry_count forever.
The retry action now retires a task to dead at the cap.
DEAD ON ARRIVAL. Tasks() never selected plan or source, so the
"Decision required" panel could not render and chat tasks -- whose issue
number is synthetic -- linked to forge issues that do not exist.
COSMETIC FAILURE, FATAL RESULT. OpenPR failed the whole stage when
LinkBranch errored, so the pull request was never opened and the task
parked; a retry re-links the same branch, which Gitea answers with a
conflict, so every retry parked again. It is best-effort now.
INVISIBLE ACTIONS. Approve/retry/reject wrote store rows and nothing
else, so the timeline and activity stream never showed that a human had
intervened. They emit events now.
Also: store write failures answer 500 rather than 409; the dashboard
surfaces the server's actual reason instead of "409 Conflict"; action
buttons stop propagation (acting on a task no longer also expands it),
disable in flight, keep per-task errors instead of one shared string,
and confirm before rejecting.
Removed: the maybeRetryParked shim and markDead with their now-vacuous
tests, WaitingTasks (no consumers; its tests were rewritten to assert
the same routing through TaskByID), write-only Daemon.Runtime, and
dir/dirs response bloat from /api/skills. skillSource checked workDir
before sharedDir, mislabelling every shared skill when the two are equal.
DefaultRoots now dedupes roots differing only by a trailing separator.
The air build rule claiming to keep ui/dist current never ran -- it
required one file to satisfy include_dir and include_file together, and
ui/ is excluded from the walk. Deleted with the comment that promised it.
task test:ui joins task check and CI; it ran nowhere before, so the
dashboard suite could rot silently.
Docs corrected where they described behaviour that no longer exists:
parks no longer comment on the issue, state labels no longer drive
retries, and forgerpc's doc claimed four proxied methods while listing
three of five.
Checkpoint commit covering concurrent work across several archie-core-abg
epics to avoid losing in-progress state:
- Memory manager (18.7-18.16): background sync pipeline, prefetch with
timeout, memory-write notification, threat scanning, shutdown drain
with abandoned-write tracking, frozen snapshot pattern. Wired
ScanContent and NotifyMemoryToolWrite into HandleToolCall so scanning
and notification actually apply to writes, not just exist as unused
primitives.
- Fixed a literal unresolved merge-conflict that had been committed to
internal/memory/scrubber/scrubber.go.
- Tool provider/registry, MCP client/transport (stdio, HTTP, SSE),
multimodal results, disclosure.
- Pairing device auth store, rate limiting.
- Gateway compression, session store, tasks.
- Various workflow, plugin host, and agentexec updates.
Implements the full PRD (docs/prds/yaegi-plugin-system.md): repos can
now define .archie/gate.go for diff-inspecting quality rules shell
commands can't express, .archie/stages/*.go for custom pipeline steps,
and skills can ship Go scripts run via a new run_go_script agent tool —
all interpreted in-process with Yaegi, with panics recovered so a bad
script can't take down the daemon. Hot reload (phase 4) needed no code:
every loader reads from disk per call and every task gets a fresh
clone, so nothing is ever cached to go stale.
The first feature run parked exactly as designed but for an avoidable
reason: todo is a templ project and the agent edited generated
_templ.go files, leaving literal template placeholders in rendered
HTML. Systemic fixes, all environmental:
- repos gain protect = ["_templ.go"]: suffixes agents can never write
(agentloop.ProtectPaths), forcing edits to the sources; the gate's
new leading ["templ","generate","./components/"] command
regenerates. AgentStage.ProtectPaths now composes with the repo list
and takes TaskContext like every other stage hook.
- archied -requeue <task-id>: the retry path for parked/waiting tasks
(keeps the task's workflow; Requeue with empty workflow preserves it,
clears the park reason).
Retry of the parked feature task drove the full loop home: PRD-guided
plan -> builder edited components.templ (generated file write-blocked),
gate regenerated + tested -> PR #8 with 109 lines of tests.
Routed via the feature label. Stages: assess (read-only agent with a
structured decide tool — verdict as a tool call, not parsed prose;
not-a-fit closes the issue as won't-do with reasons) -> PRD (read-only
agent; problem, solution, surface, acceptance criteria, non-goals) ->
deliver (PRD posted as the watched issue comment, optional [notify]
webhook POST for n8n->email, task -> waiting_human).
The daemon's cycle now watches waiting_human tasks: replies after the
watch comment (excluding the bot) are judged by an LLM (triage role,
APPROVE/REJECT/UNCLEAR + reason — never keyword matching). Approvals
requeue under implement (whose planner now treats an existing PRD as
prior context); rejections close with the reasoning acknowledged;
unclear replies keep waiting.
Supporting changes: forge.Comment returns the comment id;
forge.RepliesAfter; store watch_comment_id (additive migration),
WaitingTasks, Requeue; Route honours a pre-assigned workflow;
AgentStage.Extra for stage-specific tools.
Live: todo#7 assessed fit -> PRD delivered -> waiting_human.
AgentStage is the reusable bridge from workflow stages to agentloop
runs: role->model selection from config, budgets, repo gate conversion,
task-row NotesStore (survives worktree cleanup, never pollutes the PR),
and park-on-anything-but-passed. Every future LLM stage (tdd,
feasibility) is an AgentStage with a different mission/gate/handler.
The implement workflow: prepare -> baseline gate (park on red base,
prevents park-storms) -> plan (read-only agentloop, plan posted to the
issue as a veto window) -> build (full toolset behind the repo's
configured gate) -> commit/push -> diff cap -> PR with the builder's
finish summary as the body.
Proven live on samcharles93/todo#3: planner 3 steps, builder 4 steps
(~31k tokens total), producing gate-verified table-driven TodoStore
tests as PR #4.